top_left top_right
bottom_left
Next Event: Unknown | Forum Rules | QGL Website | Event Registration
openFolder AusForums.com
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder LANs
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder QGL
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder QGL Forum
Author
Topic: google stadia - future of gaming?
Spook
Posts: 41294
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
looks interesting, play any game anywhere you got internets.

https://www.gamesradar.com/au//google-stadia-release-date-price-games-controller/

will be interested to see costs associated:

Google Stadia is Google's game streaming service, which aims to let you play games over the internet on any internet-connected device you already own. All the games, and the hardware itself, sits in the cloud, and you're just streaming the games to your devices - like streaming a movie or TV show on Netflix, just with games instead. What that means is that everything is instant - no download times, no updates, no patches, no nothing - and you'll be able to play games in 4K with HDR at 60fps, and even upscaled to 8K (and 120fps) if you're lucky enough to rock a device that outputs at that resolution. It will also offer cross-platform multiplayer, additional support for local split-screen co-op, and more when it's fully revealed no doubt.
system
--
Twisted
Posts: 12381
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Looks s***. I've got FTTN, therefore you can guarantee I'll go to play and I won't have Internet. I imagine as new services launch all your titles will start disappearing too, just like they do on Netflix. Doesn't look at all PC orientated.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39765
Location: Other International

OnLive launched at GDC as well, in 2009. Same kind of service. It didn't really get anywhere. It's a neat idea but relies on decent and fairly flawless Internet.
Spook
Posts: 41295
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
i switched over to nbn start of feb.

mine has been flawless 100/40 10 ping since then.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39766
Location: Other International

c'n'p from another post I made today:

True story from just last night: I was playing a game of Dota 2 with a couple mates. My partner returned home mid-game and I immediately started lagging hard, resulting in one of my teammates getting killed when I made some bad moves.

The reason? My partner's phone re-connected to the wifi once she was in range and started syncing with Google Photos (a bunch of photos and videos). This floods my upstream connection (a cool 1Mbit) and kills performance until uploads are complete.

So for me, I'm worried Stadia would be this experience - but also in my single player games.

It's great if you have NBN (and it works) but for those of us that live in the middle of nowhere, where apparently it makes no sense to run fibre (2km from BNE CBD), I can't see it being great.

There's also a host of other issues that suck (games will vanish when providers get sick of them or a new version comes out, no modding, no resales, etc), but I suspect the majority of people won't mind about that, and we're far enough down that road already
hardware
Posts: 11820
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I would assume one significant caveat of this is that you don't have a 1mbit upload

And as anti-nbn as i was, the 50/20 plan i'm on has been flawless (FTTP)
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39767
Location: Other International

I think it'll be less about the speed and more about dropped packets. Streaming is actually (usually) super efficient in terms of how much you download vs how much you need to upload so it's possible 1mbit might be enough (at least for lower resolutions). But as soon as you start dropping packets you'll have painful stuttery gameplay.
Ickus
Posts: 657
Location: Perth, Western Australia

From the perspective of someone who works in the AU telecommunications industry, Australia's consumer internets and CPE routers are not up to doing this yet.

Between NBN capabilities and RSP bandwidth allocations the the potential for packetloss and jitter is significant during peak periods. Both will ruin your performance in interactive streaming.

Then there is the problem of budget routers not have sufficient QoS functionality to correctly identify and control which protocols get priority. Which would go a fair way to stopping other people using your 'priority' traffic over something not latency/jitter sensitive.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39769
Location: Other International

yeh, the two mates I play Dota with who are on NBN get way worse packetloss/general connectivity than I do on my crappy ADSL2 which peaks at 14Mbit/sec. The worst one is the guy on HFC who was force-moved from Telstra Cable to NBN - I don't get how it could, but he reckons it's much worse since then.
Twisted
Posts: 12382
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

mine has been flawless 100/40 10 ping since then.
That's called winning the NBN lottery, unlike the other 50% of the country. 100/40 is a pipe dream for me, something they talk about in far away lands.
Spook
Posts: 41296
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
i enjoy very much my suburbs facey group of which a lot is complaining about nbn. im not sure why my connection is so good, if its a combination of people not understanding how wireless works, or just aussie nbn is actually doing something different.

but yer, if i had regular dorp outs or sub standard internets, id be absolutely spewing.
reload!
Posts: 7758
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
iinet here and get steady ~96/38, it's f***ing dope
hi5 spook
Spook
Posts: 41297
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
/like
Vash
Posts: 5947
Location:

Going by Twitch's rival, Mixer, and it's ability to stream at near zero latency at reasonable bitrates, i wonder what these services would be like without the strain of local streaming & encoding.



Me streaming via mixer and running the stream on my laptop.
Pretty impressive drop in latency vs Twitch.
IVY_MiKe
Posts: 2183
Location: Canberra, Australian Capital Territory

And as anti-nbn as i was, the 50/20 plan i'm on has been flawless (FTTP)


I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest, if you own the property you have that service in, that you shouldn't be that upset about NBN (well, at least not for what you've now got out of it anyway).


Not wanting to derail the thread in to 'the broader Australian upset' that is the NBN's s***ty rollout... I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest that 'live streaming games' /would/ work, but only for certain game types.

e.g. Playing something like Sid Meier's Civilization series wouldn't be an issue. However trying to play something where even digital signal processing can affect the gamers performance (anyone here play anything on a 1.5 or 4k TV yet? more specifically) just isn't going to work streamed, no matter where you are in relation to the game.
I don't think competitive FPS' hold the 'top dog' for gaming performance as much as it did even 10 years ago, but given the levels of input lag using 'Steams in-home streaming' present, unless someone's suddenly identified how to make things travel faster than light, it's still going to be an issue for some games.

It seems to me to be misleading to suggest that 'this will be the next big thing' for gaming... as an industry, and a market, it's become so fragmented that I doubt the next big thing is going to be anything but Fortnite for a little while yet...
simul
Posts: 1674
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Google Stadia, available worldwide *

* In Australia requires at least NBN3 speeds

Please note, if you ever stated "fibre is overkill for most people and a waste of government money", you only have yourself to blame.

Note: Now living in the US, I get 1000/1000 uncapped for $80 a month.

last edited by simul at 03:11:11 25/Mar/19
Spook
Posts: 41298
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
1000mpbs?

wow.
IVY_MiKe
Posts: 2184
Location: Canberra, Australian Capital Territory

Note: Now living in the US, I get 1000/1000 uncapped for $80 a month.


I don't /hate/ you but I hate you...

I'm currently living in the 3rd world, and the ADSL speed is better than I ever got out of Canberra, WHEN IT WORKS... and the other thing I'm noticing, is that DNS and routing from where I am is a total mess... half of the time, any web requests are simply met with a DNS error... "I'm quite sure Google.com isn't down ..."
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39771
Location: Other International

Please note, if you ever stated "fibre is overkill for most people and a waste of government money", you only have yourself to blame.
Fortnight alone made $3b profit in the last year. It's not clear to me that it's the government's role to make sure people get low pings to play games. It's not clear to me that building the information megaultrasuperhighway for the purpose of exporting money to overseas games developers and international megacorps like Google will have the ROI people think it will.
Note: Now living in the US, I get 1000/1000 uncapped for $80 a month.
Pretty awesome, but there aren't many places in the US where you can get fibre, let alone for that cheap a price. Is that Google Fibre?
system
--
Not a new post since your last visit.
New Post Since your last visit
Back To Forum
Advertise with Us | Privacy Policy | Contact Us
© Copyright 2001-2019 AusGamers Pty Ltd. ACN 093 772 242.
Hosted by Mammoth Networks - Australian VPS Hosting
Web development by Mammoth Media.