top_left top_right
bottom_left
Next Event: Unknown | Forum Rules | QGL Website | Event Registration
openFolder AusForums.com
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder LANs
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder QGL
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder QGL Forum
Author
Topic: Political Thread 2.5 (Because we really haven't made any pro... Page: < 1 2 3 4 ... 10 11 12 13 >
dazedandconfused
Posts: 597
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

However, it is entirely possible that the opinion of a person or institution of authority is wrong; therefore the authority that such a person or institution holds does not have any intrinsic bearing upon whether their claims are true or not.


So it's not at all almost the exact opposite. Besides, I'm not the one making the claim that the "consensus" is the end of the argument. The burden of proof is on the claimant and the argument from authority is not an argument.
fpot
Posts: 26363
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Kind of sick of hearing you being wrong about climate change and how scientific consensus works. Why don't you tell us your thoughts on Donald Trump and the deep state conspiracy attempting to undermine him instead?
PornoPete
Posts: 3149
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Hey dazed why don't you ask fpot to explain Russian collusion.

Personally I think a three country strike on Russian assets in Syria was exactly what Putin was trying to achieve by "electing" Trump.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39563
Location: Other International

So it's not at all almost the exact opposite.
Not sure you read that quote right; it's the difference between a consensus and cherry picking "the opinion of a person or institution". Here is another definition that explains it better than I probably can.
Besides, I'm not the one making the claim that the "consensus" is the end of the argument.
The "argument" never ends though; science is a process. But there is a practical point at which you can say "there's no point in arguing about this any more because the currently available evidence, data and analysis is comprehensive enough to have formed a theory". That's pretty much where we are now.
The burden of proof is on the claimant and the argument from authority is not an argument.
yes that is why scientists have spent the last couple decades gathering data and analysing it and why the vast vast majority of them agree that something is going on here. their proof is the megatons of papers that have been published on the topic.

if you don't believe the specifics on scientific grounds then it's either that you disbelieve their data or you think their analysis is wrong. You've either done the work yourself and disagree based on one of these two areas - or you're deferring to an authority that does. I don't really have the energy to debate this topic again but I'd be interested in knowing why you think what you think, just out of morbid curiosity.
PornoPete
Posts: 3150
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

It involves denial, dismissal, unwarranted doubt or contrarian views contradicting the scientific opinion on climate change, including the extent to which it is caused by humans, its impacts on nature and human society, or the potential of adaptation to global warming by human actions
. But there is a practical point at which you can say "there's no point in arguing about this any more because the currently available evidence, data and analysis is comprehensive enough to have formed a theory". That's pretty much where we are now.


Seems doubtful to me that you could say there is consensus beyond "human activity releasing certain chemicals into the atmosphere is strongly correlated with a general trend of rising temperatures measured globally supporting a causal inference"

Vash quote includes a lot more than though.

And let's not pretend he actually believes that. It's a safe bet he actually means the entire greens policy suite is supported by the aforementioned unassailable consensus.

So actually, when you talk about deferring to authority it is very easy to slip into the authority fallacy. It is exactly how vash is using it.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 598
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Kind of sick of hearing you being wrong about climate change and how scientific consensus works. Why don't you tell us your thoughts on Donald Trump and the deep state conspiracy attempting to undermine him instead?


Your arguments are never more nuanced, complex or thought-out than "you're wrong" so I'll pass.

So actually, when you talk about deferring to authority it is very easy to slip into the authority fallacy. It is exactly how vash is using it.


This is what I was saying. I'm not getting into the climate change debate ever again, except for pointing out the broken logic of people supporting the golden idol of "scientific consensus".
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39564
Location: Other International

I'm not getting into the climate change debate ever again
yeh I'm with you on that
except for pointing out the broken logic of people supporting the golden idol of "scientific consensus".
... as long as you remember almost literally everything else in your life around you that keeps you alive, ensures you're productive, allows you to type words on a magic box and have them transmitted around the world in a tiny amount of time and appearing on everyone's screen... all that stuff is done because of scientific consensus. it is not perfect, but it improves over time with new evidence and new data, and it's the best thing we have to inform us about the universe around us so that we can make informed decisions
PornoPete
Posts: 3151
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

as long as you remember almost literally everything else in your life around you that keeps you alive, ensures you're productive, allows you to type words on a magic box and have them transmitted around the world in a tiny amount of time and appearing on everyone's screen... all that stuff is done because of scientific consensus. it is not perfect, but it improves over time with new evidence and new data, and it's the best thing we have to inform us about the universe around us so that we can make informed decisions


Gee I wonder if trog realises how big a red herring this is.

There is a massive difference between understanding science's role in developing technology, and claiming opinion on a subject is incontrovertible because there is a scientific consensus loosely related but you can't even describe.
notgreazy
Posts: 917
Location: Other International

claiming opinion on a subject is incontrovertible because there is a scientific consensus loosely related but you can't even describe.
Not trolling but what do you even mean? I can't understand your point.
Nmag
Posts: 985
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Apparently there is scientific consensus that is loosely related so the theory is still open for debate.

I think my reset option #2 was simpler. What did you think of option 2?

Do you agree the cycle would just start again, because that's what humans and other animals and even plants tend to do?
PornoPete
Posts: 3152
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Not trolling but what do you even mean? I can't understand your point.


I don't feel it is especially complicated.

The scientific consensus on climate change is on a fairly narrow set of facts. Such as some human activity is a cause of climate change. So unless you're stating I believe human activity is a cause of climate change, if you cite the scientific consensus on climate change, you're performing a combination of a red herring and an appeal to authority. Specifically a fallacious appeal to authority.

Take an opinion, for example we should end coal fired power generation.

The global scientific consensus does not extend to that opinion. Ar5 of the IPCC explicitly makes a point of not endorsing specific policies because they quote "involve value judgements of a non scientific nature".

It follows that literally any political position almost certainly cannot appeal to the scientific consensus on climate change to support its argument, except for the utterly banal point that climate change is real.

Or to make a less controversial example, there is a scientific consensus that light affects certain chemicals in ways that cause us to experience colour which in turn allows for the creation of paint. You explain to me how that fact justifies painting a cat and not a dog.

or to put it in a suitably condescending c*** phrasing. I hate that you paint cats and not dogs, I hope you realise the scientific consensus on paint enables you to paint at all.
Sir Redhat
Posts: 2216
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Gee I wonder if trog realises how big a red herring this is.

There is a massive difference between understanding science's role in developing technology, and claiming opinion on a subject is incontrovertible because there is a scientific consensus loosely related but you can't even describe.


Is there a massive difference between coal fired power plants contributing to climate change and painting cats or dogs?
PornoPete
Posts: 3153
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

That feeling when you mistake a red herring because you committed a straw man.

I don't think you understand what a scientific consensus is. That's ok. But I hope you realise that a scientific consensus allows you to write dreary logical fallacies on the internet.

It makes modern life possible don't you know.

Try replacing cats and dogs with banning gas powerplants or banning coal powerplants.
Raven
Posts: 9593
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
I'd like to recommend a book that it seems all of you need to read.

https://www.amazon.com/Illustrated-Book-Bad-Arguments/dp/1615192255/ref=pd_sim_14_2?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=1615192255&pd_rd_r=MFQG3RA7G7F99X7KSFKS&pd_rd_w=9lm1q&pd_rd_wg=QNGGG&psc=1&refRID=MFQG3RA7G7F99X7KSFKS
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39566
Location: Other International

seems like a lot of effort and expense when a single page with "why bother" written in crayon would do the job
PornoPete
Posts: 3154
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

seems like a lot of effort and expense when a single page with "why bother" written in crayon would do the job


It funny that you block people who talk to you exactly as you talk to others.

I don't think you're giving enough respect to the scientific consensus on crayons here.
notgreazy
Posts: 918
Location: Other International


I don't feel it is especially complicated.
The scientific consensus on climate change is on a fairly narrow set of facts. Such as some human activity is a cause of climate change. So unless you're stating I believe human activity is a cause of climate change, if you cite the scientific consensus on climate change, you're performing a combination of a red herring and an appeal to authority. Specifically a fallacious appeal to authority.

Just gonna concentrate on this first paragraph because the rest doesn't really add anything. This is a really dumb argument to put forward. Let's assume for the sake of argument that you are correct, the current scientific consensus on climate change is based on few facts and does not take into account the whole picture... But you still think they're wrong.

You are arguing against the collective knowledge of several thousand people who have spent the majority of their adult life studying the climate. If you had 1001 plumbers telling you "don't dig there, it's a bad idea" yet you still think they're wrong? They haven't investigating ever facet of the problem, for what reason? If they could they would.

What a dumb argument.
infi
Posts: 24049
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

You are arguing against the collective knowledge of several thousand people who have spent the majority of their adult life studying the climate. If you had 1001 plumbers telling you "don't dig there, it's a bad idea" yet you still think they're wrong? They haven't investigating ever facet of the problem, for what reason? If they could they would.


in global macro economics they call this "everyone being on one side of the boat". it's a classic opportunity to get squeezed, and typically the person who holds the other view makes a fortune because instead of being 99% right forecasters are generally less than 50% right. risk management means to have appropriately sized risks in either camp, and not betting the house (by say disabling your economic growth) on a strongly held view.
fpot
Posts: 26364
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Human caused climate change is a certainty. Not a near certainty, not a strong possibility, a certainty. Let's pretend for a moment though that it was a 50/50 proposition. Do you think taking measures to prevent it would be a worthy step despite the disruption to economic growth compared to pretending it doesn't exist and the catastrophe that would (will) entail?
PornoPete
Posts: 3155
Location: Melbourne, Victoria


Just gonna concentrate on this first paragraph because the rest doesn't really add anything. This is a really dumb argument to put forward. Let's assume for the sake of argument that you are correct, the current scientific consensus on climate change is based on few facts and does not take into account the whole picture... But you still think they're wrong.


I don't think it's possible for you to have misunderstood more profoundly.

The consensus is about certain facts in the natural world.

It does not tell you what you should do.

The IPCC explicitly make this statement.

The fact that coal powerplants contribute to climate change does not without more justify turning them all off. This is because there are a range of other considerations and options which the climate science is silent on.

Acknowledgeing these other important factors absolutely does not run against the scientific consensus on climate change. It is the opinion of The scientific community which forms the IPCC. They freely acknowledge other factors may trump their input. Nothing about that says climate science is wrong.

I am directly quoting from their report my emphasis

Natural, technical, and social sciences can provide essential information and evidence needed for decisions on what constitutes "dangerous anthropogenic interference" with the climate system. At the same time, such decisions are value judgments determined through socio-political processes, taking into account considerations such as development, equity, and sustainability, as well as uncertainties and risk. Scientific evidence helps to reduce uncertainty and increase knowledge, and can serve as an input for considering precautionary measures.1 Decisions are based on risk assessment, and lead to risk management choices by decision makers, about actions and policies


I don't know how to make it clearer to you.

The scientific consensus doesn't without a broad range of other considerations justify a particular policy. The peak body representing climate scientists is very clear on this point.

So call it a dumb argument if you want. It's the argument made by the 1000 plumbers you're talking about.
infi
Posts: 24050
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

appropriately sized measures, yes. a carbon tax, reducing the standard of living and funding larger bureaucracy, is not an appropriately sized measure actively . encouraging energy efficiency and allowing the natural evolution of alternative energy sources is.

i think it is far more important for major emitters to make significant reductions, than to expect minnows to start first. it is technological innovation which will pave the way for less energy usage and investment which delivers financial returns.
notgreazy
Posts: 919
Location: Other International


Ahaha the IPCC is a bureaucratic s***hole on the same level as the WHO and UN. It is a juggernaut whose movements and results are more akin to a sloth on a highway. Continuing this analogy, if IPCC is a sloth, global warming is a jaguar. We are so f***ed.

FYI that quote is from a report 11 years ago, which itself is quoting a 2001 report.

You are also ignoring a very important note, scientists have shifted from "we can stop climate change" to "we're f***ed, how do we manage the situation?". This is evident all the way back nearly 20 years ago. Everytime you claim I am appealing to authority, you quote IPCC.... nice appeal to authority. Also quoting a tiny bit of a IPCC summary of another IPCC report is itself a red herring. Let's go see what the IPCC says...


The reason for incorporating other non-scientific factors:

http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/tar/vol4/index.php?idp=7

The climate change issue is part of the larger challenge of sustainable development. As a result, climate policies can be more effective when consistently embedded within broader strategies designed to make national and regional development paths more sustainable. This occurs because the impact of climate variability and change, climate policy responses, and associated socio-economic development will affect the ability of countries to achieve sustainable development goals. Conversely, the pursuit of those goals will in turn affect the opportunities for, and success of, climate policies. In particular, the socio-economic and technological characteristics of different development paths will strongly affect emissions, the rate and magnitude of climate change, climate change impacts, the capability to adapt, and the capacity to mitigate.


The scientific consensus is not "loosely related", it directly drives the actions required to deviate from the path of destruction. Other factors are incorporated into decision making to increase the effect of the outcome.

info: f*** you for putting profits first.
fpot
Posts: 26365
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

encouraging energy efficiency and allowing the natural evolution of alternative energy sources is.
This sounds suspiciously like do nothing and hope everything turns out fine to me, which in the context of the 50/50 scenario I gave you is not so bad I guess.

The reality is that climate change is real, it's too late to stop it and now the only goal is to minimise the damage it causes - do you still think the do nothing and hope approach is still appropriate?
Nmag
Posts: 986
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I keep telling you guys #2, the reset option is the way.

We can have a revolution with placards and everything. Cumon, lets do it this Saturday at about lunch time.

Maybe we could discuss option #3 Candle vigil, with thoughts and prayers for our dieing planet.

We could link arms and sing kum-by-yah and have a peaceful protest of love. Maybe we do that at night, cause the candles look better in the dark.

#2 will be the most fun.

https://mdrtresourcezone.blob.core.windows.net/web-site/image/_asset/e6385eacfc1c42e7aea3a77d00e72b82/reset button.jpg
PornoPete
Posts: 3156
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

In the paragraph directly above the one you quote. My emphasis.

The basis for determining what constitutes "dangerous anthropogenic interference" will vary among regions -- depending both on the local nature and consequences of climate change impacts, and also on the adaptive capacity available to cope with climate change -- and depends upon mitigative capacity, since the magnitude and the rate of change are both important. There is no universally applicable best set of policies; rather, it is important to consider both the robustness of different policy measures against a range of possible future worlds, and the degree to which such climate-specific policies can be integrated with broader sustainable development policies.


They repeatedly state concerns beyond climate change mitigation can and should be incorporated into policy. You say it yourself when you talk about making them effective. If you destroy people's standard of living in the process you will not get the political will necessary to make a change. I really don't understand how you don't understand this.

FYI that quote is from a report 11 years ago, which itself is quoting a 2001 report.


The issue of policy matters beyond climate change is in the 2014 report. Its like there is no real doubt among the experts on this point.

This is evident all the way back nearly 20 years ago. Everytime you claim I am appealing to authority, you quote IPCC.... nice appeal to authority. Also quoting a tiny bit of a IPCC summary of another IPCC report is itself a red herring. Let's go see what the IPCC says...


See this is you misunderstanding the point profoundly. But it's pretty funny to be chastised about climate science for agreeing with what the peak body on climate science says about how to develop policy.

If you can provide a better source for a synthesis of the state of the research I'm all ears.

The authority fallacy happens when you claim the scientific consensus supports your opinion when it doesn't. Given what they state they have consensus on the range of policies that could unequivocally supported by the consensus is correspondingly narrow.
Sir Redhat
Posts: 2217
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I keep telling you guys #2, the reset option is the way.

We can have a revolution with placards and everything. Cumon, lets do it this Saturday at about lunch time.

Maybe we could discuss option #3 Candle vigil, with thoughts and prayers for our dieing planet.

We could link arms and sing kum-by-yah and have a peaceful protest of love. Maybe we do that at night, cause the candles look better in the dark.

#2 will be the most fun.


The reset option happened after the world wars, it's discussed in the Pickety book i mentioned earlier. There was less inequality after war. I don't think he had data for the french revolution.

Given that war and revolution would be the very last options on the table don't you think wealth taxes would be the most sensible way forward?
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39567
Location: Other International

This sounds suspiciously like do nothing and hope everything turns out fine to me, which in the context of the 50/50 scenario I gave you is not so bad I guess.

The reality is that climate change is real, it's too late to stop it and now the only goal is to minimise the damage it causes - do you still think the do nothing and hope approach is still appropriate?
the important thing is to make sure that under no circumstances we tax anyone no matter how badly they're taking advantage of externalities to be profitable at the expense of everyone else
Nmag
Posts: 987
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

don't you think wealth taxes would be the most sensible way forward?


I think if super rich people started pumping out more children and educating them, while the super poor stopped breeding completely, things would start getting more sensible.

The savings would provide such an abundance of wealth that even the poorest would have a quantum leap in living standards. The super rich could hire the super poor as help around the house. The super rich could house and feed all the poor. You would need a good way to deal with the help if they were lazy though. Maybe military for a couple years would help motivate them?

Also, "#2 Reset" is inevitable. One day a meteor will wipe us out, and then the cycle will start again.
Vash
Posts: 5770
Location:

Nmag you need to be more subtle with the trolling. Learn from PP.
fpot
Posts: 26367
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Yeah paraphrasing Russian Twitter bots worked very well for PP maybe you should give that a crack.
PornoPete
Posts: 3157
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Yeah paraphrasing Russian Twitter bots worked very well for PP maybe you should give that a crack.


Glorious. Everything that doesn't fit into my uninformed world view (which is slightly less mature than a 13 year old's) is "Russian bots".

Makes sense he identifies high school student political thought.
Nmag
Posts: 988
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Many social liberal ideals are very suitable for young single lifestyle, but become a lot less relatable after people get into their 30s, get married, and have kids - now the thought of "family values" or "protecting the children" is a lot more relevant. Having children is a strong predictor of more right-wing social views.
https://www.quora.com/Why-do-we-generally-as-citizens-become-more-right-wing-as-we-grow-older

As I could explain it, eventually the penny drops that the people who are committing crimes that put you and your family at risk are most likely scum that are being funded through welfare by their victims. Also as you get wiser you realise there are people who suffer from "laziness" and the same people tend to want to blame others. You start to notice that losers are less likely to accept responsibility for their own poor state of affairs, more likely to blame or despise the successful, and are very quick at finding excuses and convincing each other than 'someone else is to blame'. You start to wonder if these people had put more effort into competitive team sport they might be better adjusted at understanding that achievement comes with effort and lazy players go on the bench, or do not get selected for the team.

So then you start to wonder.. why are we supporting losers so much? And you realise that if we did not, crime would go through the roof.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7846
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Glorious corruption and wage theft comrades!

http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2018-04-21/sally-zou-faces-court-over-1-million-unpaid-wages-claim/9682352?pfmredir=sm
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39571
Location: Other International

never heard of that person but she sounds like a WILD CARD
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7847
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Lol Scott Morrison said we didn't need a Banking Royal Commission.

Sir Redhat
Posts: 2218
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


He also blamed Bill for the delays.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-04-20/morrison-blames-bill-shorten-for-delay-to-banking/9679818

You're in gov mate.


PornoPete
Posts: 3158
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Is that really how you summarise that video?
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7848
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Kelly O'Liar

Sir Redhat
Posts: 2219
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Is that really how you summarise that video?

Yep i summarised it in 1 sentence because I am a big brain man. Please defend the video, instead of just posting some contrarian s***.
PornoPete
Posts: 3159
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

If that "big brain" of yours reached Bill shorten was the cause of the delay based on Morrison's words in that video you may need to see a doctor cause it ain't grey matter taking up the space.

The question was should he apologize for questioning the need for a commission at all.

The answer to that is still no. Bill wanted the commission as payback for the union Commission, in the hope it would be equally embarrassing for the libs.

His comments about shorten are precise.

If Billy Boy was serious he should have able to put forward draft terms of reference.
infi
Posts: 24051
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

I saw this and immediately thought of the Socialist nuts on QGL.

https://i.imgur.com/cFkiXnN.jpg
Jim
Posts: 13748
Location: UK

none of those are real socialism - we've never tried the version of socialism I'm a proponent of
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39573
Location: Other International

https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/subgenius/images/8/89/Cat_matrix_deja_vu.gif/revision/latest?cb=20160306191811
Nmag
Posts: 989
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


This website will provide insight into how to cope with infi's image regarding 'fictional country'.

https://circuitglobe.com/difference-between-short-circuit-and-overload.html


dazedandconfused
Posts: 599
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

none of those are real socialism - we've never tried the version of socialism I'm a proponent of


Yes that's because it is only possible in a fantasy universe.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39574
Location: Other International

speaking of fantasy universes
fpot
Posts: 26370
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Someone somewhere in a fantasy universe is describing our universe as a fantasy universe.
PornoPete
Posts: 3160
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

speaking of fantasy universes

It's unbecoming to masturbate to your idea of a libertarian argument in public trog. Please keep your fantasies to yourself.
infi
Posts: 24052
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

speaking of fantasy universes


an edgy yet ignorant attempt to poke fun at actual libertarian philosophy. i had to bleach my eyes.

Someone somewhere in a fantasy universe is describing our universe as a fantasy universe.


meta, incomprehensible.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39575
Location: Other International

the ironing is delicious
Sir Redhat
Posts: 2221
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Why do the anti communist/socialist arguments always bring up Venezuela but not China?

China's ruling party says they're communist. So obviously they completely are. Checkmate capitalists.
PornoPete
Posts: 3161
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

the ironing is delicious


for who.

Why do the anti communist/socialist arguments always bring up Venezuela but not China?


Wow, that "big brain" of yours thought that was a point or something. I get how your summary managed to not capture a single thing Morrison said now. You also need to like talk with Vash. He seems to think the name is not that important.
infi
Posts: 24053
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

China's ruling party says they're communist. So obviously they completely are. Checkmate capitalists.


oh that's brilliance.
Vash
Posts: 5771
Location:

Why do the anti communist/socialist arguments always bring up Venezuela but not China?


It's interesting isn't it. A state controlled economy, with market elements (just like Venezuela) has an economy growing faster than the libertarian paradise that is the USA, yet they're very quiet about China.
taggs
Posts: 6550
Location:




It's interesting isn't it. A state controlled economy, with market elements (just like Venezuela) has an economy growing faster than the libertarian paradise that is the USA, yet they're very quiet about China.
literally the first econ 101 on the subject i could google

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solow%E2%80%93Swan_model

Just in case that was hard to understand and just to make clear why literally every historically underdeveloped economy has outgrown developed economies in absolute growth terms on an avg basis when opened up to market forces edit: or even when not (see Paul Samuelson's famous (repeatedly wrong over decades) forecasts in the geeky econ community as a prime example) AND they haven't been retarded by terrible governance, s***ty dictators or other dumb ass s*** (i.e. % yoy over time for a prolonged basis).

Mathematically a high growth rate off a low base.... f*** me why am i posting in this thread. f***
PornoPete
Posts: 3162
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

the ironing is delicious

for who.


TFW we aren't saying Venezuela is model to follow that's a strawman, and then Vash happens. The ironing is truly very good at this place troggles

pointing to the amazing GDP growth of a country that can get economic growth just by providing enough food (because they don't at the moment). Ah you can't buy this kind of entertainment.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7849
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
China is a polluted, over populated hell hole. Where most human beings are reduced to rice powered robots so the world can have cheap s***.

last edited by sLaps_Forehead at 10:39:01 25/Apr/18
PornoPete
Posts: 3163
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

China is a polluted, over populated hell hole.


No see China is a workers paradise where everyone lives perfect lives and walks around in a softly perfumed bubble. Which is why anti-communists are backed into such a corner.

redhat got confused when Deng started talking about the colour of cats didn't you big brains. It's ok. he was being "metaphorical". It's a trap for young players.
infi
Posts: 24054
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

pointing to the amazing GDP growth of a country that can get economic growth just by providing enough food (because they don't at the moment).


and has bank debt 2.5x that of USA. I thought the US government economy was f***ed until I started reading about China. Luckily for the Chinese government, if the citizens start to get antsy they can just shoot them or crush them with tanks.

I honestly can't believe Vash now refers to China as the socialist paradise.

Finland ends basic income experiment.
Vash
Posts: 5772
Location:

When did i say it was a Socialist paradise? Economically, they're going to surpass the U.S in the not too distant future. Funny all the strawmans coming out from all corners after that one.
PornoPete
Posts: 3164
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

When did i say it was a Socialist paradise? Economically, they're going to surpass the U.S in the not too distant future. Funny all the strawmans coming out from all corners after that one.


haha jesus, it's like watching a three-year-old, but with a shorter attention span.

Why would China surpassing the US economically be a thorn in the side of an anti-communist?

Serious question redhat, does vash ever make you facepalm? He produces a never-ending stream of illiterate nonsense. Surely it must upset you to see your best arguments mauled so badly.
Nmag
Posts: 990
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Chinese are brainwashed by the state from birth. Listening to someone from China supporting communism is like listening to a door-to-door Joseph Smith follower.

One day in the lunch room at this place I once worked, this ex Chinese woman asks me what I think about communism, and then proceeds to explain that it works quite well in China. I did't make any comment, but I did have some thoughts about what I'd like to say to her. She was some low paid office admin idiot. I couldn't believe she came out with her comments.

There should have been some phone number I can ring to report we have a treasonous spy from China working here and needs to be returned to a national with a political environment more aligned with her views.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39576
Location: Other International

When did i say it was a Socialist paradise? Economically, they're going to surpass the U.S in the not too distant future. Funny all the strawmans coming out from all corners after that one.
who gives a s*** if they don't have a democracy and all their wealthy citizens are desperately trying to offshore their wealth by buying real estate outside of the country

I wouldn't take America's GDP as an indicator of how great it is and I don't recommend doing it for China either
Vash
Posts: 5773
Location:

Yes all horrid things. But you dont hear China as a failed Socialist or Communist experiment do you? It's economic might is on display for all.
PornoPete
Posts: 3165
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

But you dont hear China as a failed Socialist or Communist experiment do you? It's economic might is on display for all.


Literally because they stopped trying to run their economy in the communist style. How is the level of stupidity possible?
Sir Redhat
Posts: 2223
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Literally because they stopped trying to run their economy in the communist style. How is the level of stupidity possible?

Yeah it's completely a free market. hahahahahahhahhahahhahahhhahahhahah
PornoPete
Posts: 3166
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Yeah it's completely a free market. hahahahahahhahhahahhahahhhahahhahah


You don't know what the Shanghai free trade zone is, do you redhat?

The simple fact is their increase in wealth is directly attributable to the amount of socialism they drop, and they are dropping more by the day.

Venture capital is going gangbusters in China redhat. Hardly a socialist enterprise I'm sure you'll agree.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7850
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
China is now more of a "capitalize the profits for a few and socialize the losses for the masses" type of deal.
Sir Redhat
Posts: 2224
Location: Sydney, New South Wales



You don't know what the Shanghai free trade zone is, do you redhat?

The simple fact is their increase in wealth is directly attributable to the amount of socialism they drop, and they are dropping more by the day.

Venture capital is going gangbusters in China redhat. Hardly a socialist enterprise I'm sure you'll agree.


Correlation = causation, more news from the intellectual giant known as porno pete.

Yeah I don't know anything about shanghai trade zones, seems pretty specific if we're discussing china as a whole. Have you actually read anything? What do you read in your spare time with regards to economic policy I'd like to know.
PornoPete
Posts: 3167
Location: Melbourne, Victoria


Correlation = causation, more news from the intellectual giant known as porno pete.


haha good one redhat. Guess the 40 years of starvation and economic stagnation before deng were only "correlated" with socialism.

Have you actually read anything? What do you read in your spare time with regards to the economic policy I'd like to know.


Ah yeah so I studied WTO law, how to set up companies in China, the Australia China BIT, the basic contract law of China, and dabbled in Chinese bankruptcy scenarios as part of my degree. so I've literally read thousands of pages on how to do business in China. I also worked for a company that did a lot of business in China. Let's just say economic liberalisation in China came up a bit (as in continuously, and is continuously credited with its turn around in poverty).

I'm pretty comfortable with the CCP 30-year trend of trying liberal economic experiments, and those experiments being deployed to the entire nation. The Shanghai free trade zone being one of the more recent, and a full-blown attempt deregulated trade. It is an experiment and if they like the outcome they'll expand it. Given the rumblings out of their securities regulator about establishing institutional investors, it sounds like they like it so far.

I recently listened to a talk by peter thiel about access to venture capital in China which is where that venture capital comment came from. given he is a venture capitalist with a few billion to his name he probably knows what he is talking about.

What do you read redhat?
Vash
Posts: 5774
Location:

Venezuela also has free trade zones, and a large private industry. But the country's economy is collapsing, because of Socialism right? And because China is succeeding, it's because of Capitalism now. Heh.
PornoPete
Posts: 3168
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Venezuela also has free trade zones, and a large private industry. But the country's economy is collapsing, because of Socialism right? And because China is succeeding, it's because of Capitalism now. Heh.


Please try and pack more dumb into a couple of sentences. I was definitely hanging my hat on a single liberal economic experiment in the case of China, and not the four decades of successive trade liberalisation the free trade zone is an example of. What a f***ing idiot.


Anywho

speaking of fantasy universes


infi's meme was definitely attacking a crude rendition of people's actual beliefs. It's not like people would insist that socialism makes china and venezuela awesome or anything.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 600
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

speaking of fantasy universes


My favourite part is where trog thinks I want absolute anarcho-capitalism. My second-favourite part is where you need to make an absurd story to debunk a fantasy libertarian state whereas you just have to look at the last 12 months in any communist country to see far worse.
infi
Posts: 24056
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

it was written by a second year lit student who has a beret and a mac.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39577
Location: Other International

My favourite part is where trog thinks I want absolute anarcho-capitalism.
You've been too careful (or gutless?!) to say what you actually want; remember this conversation started (continued?) because you posted a long boring video about how capitalism is the only thing that ever did anything good for humanity. So what do you want? If you want the continuation of what we have now except with the slider favoured towards capitalism instead of socialism, then woohoo, you're almost exactly the same as me except tilted slightly in the opposite direction. How different we are!
My second-favourite part is where you need to make an absurd story
I assume you know I didn't make it but it's hard to tell and words mean things and facts matter so just want to make sure we're all on the same page
you just have to look at the last 12 months in any communist country to see far worse.
wat, strawman, we haven't been talking about communism
dazedandconfused
Posts: 601
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

...capitalism is the only thing that ever did anything good for humanity


Nope. Strawman irony below VVV

wat, strawman, we haven't been talking about communism


Communism could be seen as the extreme of socialism as anarcho-capitalism is to libertarianism. I don't know if you're pretending you don't get this basic stuff or you actually don't get it.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39578
Location: Other International

Nope. Strawman irony below VVV
I made this claim earlier and you didn't call it out as a strawman then. It's not, anyway, but it's possible I misinterpreted the video because I only skipped through it. Maybe you can summarise the video and point out what I misunderstand?
Communism could be seen as the extreme of socialism as anarcho-capitalism is to libertarianism. I don't know if you're pretending you don't get this basic stuff or you actually don't get it.
Speaking of basic stuff, are we talking about "your favourite part" - what you want, or what you don't want? maybe you could pick a conversational thread and run with it instead of deflecting or changing the topic when you're called out on it again and again and again and again
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39579
Location: Other International

it was written by a second year lit student who has a beret and a mac.
man that article (which is a piece of comedic satire) really touched a nerve amongst some of us didn't it. I'm going to POST IT AGAIN AND AGAIN
Jim
Posts: 13750
Location: UK

^ here in the UK we consider that sort of trolling to be a hate crime
catch yerself on trog (if that's even your real name)
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39581
Location: Other International

^ here in the UK we consider that sort of trolling to be a hate crime
I'm already worried I'm tripping over 18C rules here
dazedandconfused
Posts: 602
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I am not going into what I believe. I'd prefer people put their feet in their mouth and troll that.
infi
Posts: 24057
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

I'm already worried I'm tripping over 18C rules here


it's sad that thought is policed so heavily in Australia.

The article is cringey - like a uni assignment designed to impress his leftist professor. And I doubt it influenced a single person - the real test of satire.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 603
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Behold, the glory of socialism
fpot
Posts: 26373
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

So you've gone from a 'I am the dark and mysterious internet smart maens none shall ever know the deep complexities that swirl within me' to 'complex legal/medical issues are socialism's fault' while citing the daily f***ing wire of all places. No-one's got you figured out bro, that's one for the future scholars to figure out as they sift through the ruins of the Ausgamers forum. Who was this man? Was he the benevolent saviour of the alt-right subterfuging his way to the very top of the forum with his bastardised Shapiro and Posobiec regurgatite? Or was he just another scared loney little boy bleating his sad howls into the black hole of the internet, the last thing on earth that will tolerate him?
Vash
Posts: 5775
Location:

Behold, the glory of socialism


Surely you linked the wrong article. Or would you care to explain how that has anything to do with Socialism...?
PornoPete
Posts: 3169
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

while citing the daily f***ing wire of all places. No-one's got you figured out bro,


It's funny someone who links to crikey and the guardian calls out someone's source.

man that article (which is a piece of comedic satire) really touched a nerve amongst some of us didn't it.


so the blow by blow

infi posts meme which accurately reflects vash's and apparently a few others views on socialism.

Trog, deciding it was a strawman, posts a story which is a strawman of infis views (subtext "see I can strawman you too").

Vash promptly confirms infi's meme is accurate.

Trog gets sad that people point out that the strawman is asymmetrical and claims infi is super upset over his post.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 604
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

So you've gone from a 'I am the dark and mysterious internet smart maens none shall ever know the deep complexities that swirl within me' to 'complex legal/medical issues are socialism's fault' while citing the daily f***ing wire of all places. No-one's got you figured out bro, that's one for the future scholars to figure out as they sift through the ruins of the Ausgamers forum. Who was this man? Was he the benevolent saviour of the alt-right subterfuging his way to the very top of the forum with his bastardised Shapiro and Posobiec regurgatite? Or was he just another scared loney little boy bleating his sad howls into the black hole of the internet, the last thing on earth that will tolerate him?


Can anyone else hear some buzzing around here?
Nmag
Posts: 991
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Literally because they stopped trying to run their economy in the communist style. How is the level of stupidity possible?


Oh Vash I think we struck gold on this page. Shall we give it to Trog so he can divide it out evenly?

and this

China is now more of a "capitalize the profits for a few and socialize the losses for the masses" type of deal.


Maybe if Trog did divide up the gold evenly and handed it out, someone would like to take a small bit extra cause human nature?

Not in Vashland where it rains fairy glitter, and unicorns run wild.

Where is fpot hasn't replied to my true anecdote? He asked for more of them.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39582
Location: Other International

it's sad that thought is policed so heavily in Australia.
You are confusing 'thought' with 'speech', but with that correction, I'm still not sure I disagree
The article is cringey - like a uni assignment designed to impress his leftist professor. And I doubt it influenced a single person - the real test of satire.
you seem influenced as f***! so is the dude that wrote non-libertarian version (who explains in a postscript that he simply cannot understand why libertarians are the target of so many jokes). IT'S A FUNNY PIECE OF WRITING DUDE, not a critical analysis.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39583
Location: Other International

Behold, the glory of socialism
FYI one of those silly American talking heads had a similar hot take on this and was disassembled on the twitters

tldr: the state was not involved
Vash
Posts: 5776
Location:

Even if the state was involved, it has nothing to do with Socialism. Dazed chose his name well.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 605
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

FYI one of those silly American talking heads had a similar hot take on this and was disassembled on the twitters

tldr: the state was not involved


Are you legitimately claiming that the court's application of legislation is "the state was not involved"? Wow.

By the way, did you read the thread in your second link? It's hard to argue against socialists when they don't even know they are socialists.
fpot
Posts: 26374
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I guess Ronny Jackson won't be taking up that rather ahem... rewarding position after all.
PornoPete
Posts: 3170
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

You seem influenced as f***! so is the dude that wrote non-libertarian version (who explains in a postscript that he simply cannot understand why libertarians are the target of so many jokes). IT'S A FUNNY PIECE OF WRITING DUDE, not a critical analysis.


Gee saying the "funny" piece of writing isn't very funny, and written in the style of an unwashed under grad with pretensions of being "the people's poet" is really striking a nerve with poor old trog.
infi
Posts: 24058
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

i am lost as to how one could think it was funny. did you think it was funny trog? was it entertaining to you? did it contribute to discourse?
fpot
Posts: 26375
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

An image of a politician from the in power party threatening the peace and love party with death - a hilarious image unfairly treated by the fun police.

A piece of satire whose accuracy is confirmed by the gushing tears of the extreme lolbertarians in this very thread - wahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
PornoPete
Posts: 3171
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

piece of satire whose accuracy is confirmed by the gushing tears of the extreme lolbertarians in this very thread - wahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh


Seems like trog is the only one crying until now.
infi
Posts: 24059
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

i was feeling confused about the point of the "satire".
fpot
Posts: 26376
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

That's because you're one of the dumbest people alive and without a hint of self-awareness.
Nmag
Posts: 992
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Check out these commies marching in Beijing:

https://i.imgur.com/pCGsYf4.jpg
PornoPete
Posts: 3172
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Watch fpot go
dazedandconfused
Posts: 606
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I reckon fpot is only this angry on the internet. I reckon in real life he's a big sweetie.
infi
Posts: 24060
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

It's an outlet. It's hard when you know you're the smartest person in the room but no one acknowledges it.
PornoPete
Posts: 3173
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

FYI one of those silly American talking heads had a similar hot take on this and was disassembled on the twitters tldr: the state was not involved


See the trouble with Twitter is that bots reign supreme (so I'm told, you can paraphrase russian ones). Poor old trog got played by the secret barrister.

She says omg the department of health isn't a party to the proceeding haugh haugh haugh the government (in the narrow sense of the executive) wasn't involved, dummies.

But the applicant is the "Alder Hey Children's NHS Foundation Trust". Which is the Adler Hey Children's Hospital division of the NHS Foundation Trust.

You can google who controls the National Health Service Foundation Trust. I don't want to ruin the surprise.

tldr: the state was not involved


tldr: trog is as wrong as its possible to get, thanks to Twitter. Those bots. They'll gecha.
taggs
Posts: 6553
Location:

Probably could have stopped reading when someone claiming to be a barrister used the word legislative as a noun, tbh.

But the general argument that unless the party to a legal proceeding is a minister on behalf of the crown then you aren't dealing with the government is just silly.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39585
Location: Other International

Probably could have stopped reading when someone claiming to be a barrister used the word legislative as a noun, tbh.
Are you talking about the 2nd post in that Secret Barrister thread? if I go back with my anal English reading pants on I can see what you mean but you can just read it as an adjective and move on with your life and then think about the rest of the comments independently of minor lapses
But the general argument that unless the party to a legal proceeding is a minister on behalf of the crown then you aren't dealing with the government is just silly.
well, that wasn't the claim made by whatshisface earlier - it was about 'socialism'. edit: my comment was mostly about noting that blaming "socialism" broadly on the actions of a few doctors/administrators is full on moronic, right?

Re: my comment though: I guess I distinguish between "the state" and "the government", which I would concede might just be semantics, but given in the UK something like 15% of the population work for "the government" in some form or another it's kind of inevitable that at some point you're going to cross paths with THE MAN. Obviously "the government" is involved in many things, like if you have to drive somewhere, but the level of their agency in certain decisions actually matters

edit #2: I';ll be honest, I read the twitter thing and took it as way more authoritative than the blogspam that whatshisname posted. it's quite possible that dude is way off in his interpretation but maybe there's a link or something that looks at it in more detail than his misuse of grammar?
PornoPete
Posts: 3174
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Dude the simple fact is the hospital as an agent of the state sued to be allowed to turn off life support to the kid. All the "doctors not the state" were called as expert witnesses for the state.

The state far from being not involved was balls deep in it. And I mean in the exact narrow sense the barrister said it didn't. One post in and getting the law wrong is not a good look, unless the point is to rely on an absurd technicality to look the big man in front of your target audience. Seems like mission accomplished.

The rest of the argument is saying that the best interests of the child as determined by experts (specifically state experts) trump the wishes of the parents is the law of the land. Which it maybe but that is where the philosophical argument kicks in.

That's the tldr.

The "barrister" lied by omission.

You bought it cause it played to your ideological preferences. In exactly the same way dazed did I might add.

And as far as socialism maybe a crude short hand, it is still the case that the state argued it knew better than the parents what was best for the child. There is a real question about the limits of the state to intrude into private lives there. And as much as you're calling dazeds shorthand moronic you've hardly covered yourself in glory.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 607
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Post limited again just like I was a decade ago even though my posts weren't deleted. Weird moderating.
taggs
Posts: 6554
Location:

Are you talking about the 2nd post in that Secret Barrister thread? if I go back with my anal English reading pants on I can see what you mean but you can just read it as an adjective and move on with your life and then think about the rest of the comments independently of minor lapses


Yeah I know it sounds petty as f*** to a layperson (which i also am fwiw) but as someone who deals with lawyers every day as part of my job and knows first hand how pedantic many (but not all omg let's not generalise) can be I just actually can't picture in my mind's eye a barrister, i.e. someone who literally is paid thousands of dollars an hour to be very particular about language, makes that mistake. But tbh let's ignore that cause it's a nothing thing. (edit: irony of writing such a long para about something so petty not lost on me)

Sorry, to be fair I was lashing out at the dumb twitter post because this whole situation seems so f***ing stupid and it feel so gross that it's becoming a political rallying point for both the left and right. I can sort of get my head around the state refusing to treat a patient (though that is an ethical question with a lot of hairs that i haven't thought through). What I can't get my head around is the state forcibly stopping a family from leaving the country to receive treatment that the state isn't willing to offer. If that's getting this situation wrong I'm honestly interested in the counter argument is.
fpot
Posts: 26378
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

On my phone at work but the position of the NHS was that treatment wasn't possible and that travel to Italy would only cause undue suffering for no benefit. Can't easily find any details on what treatment Italy was offering or how effective it might have been. Alfie has sadly passed away.
PornoPete
Posts: 3175
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I don't think it is a nothing thing taggs. I think the following two things are closely linked. It isn't a small mistake. The idea that the NHS of the UK *isn't the government* or the state (which is a distinction without a difference in this case) is so wrong a layperson nudged will instantly see the problem.

But tbh let's ignore that cause it's a nothing thing
Sorry, to be fair I was lashing out at the dumb twitter post because this whole situation seems so f***ing stupid and it feel so gross that it's becoming a political rallying point for both the left and right


The mistake, if it was one, is part of the political rallying. So desperate to paint the otherside as knuckle dragging morons for seeing anything at all worth raising a eyebrow about, this so called barrister is willing to obscure the fact the NHS is plainly and obviously part of the executive government. Let's not forget in any other circumstances we'd be hearing about how amazing the NHS is and how dumb Republican Americans are for not wanting it. All of a sudden the NHS isn't the government, oh and Republican Americans are dumb for thinking it is. What utter twaddle.

On my phone at work but the position of the NHS was that treatment wasn't possible and that travel to Italy would only cause undue suffering for no benefit. Can't easily find any details on what treatment Italy was offering or how effective it might have been. Alfie has sadly passed away.


On what planet is that anyone's call but the parents. Climb down in 10, 9....
infi
Posts: 24061
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

What I can't get my head around is the state forcibly stopping a family from leaving the country to receive treatment that the state isn't willing to offer.


I would expect that behaviour in Russia or China, but England....

parents should (where the State has cut a patient loose) be entitled to pursue any further viable treatment options they want. And if they want to leave the country then why would the government care?
fpot
Posts: 26379
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

To steer the conversation towards a controversial issue that we actually may all agree on - legalising cannabis - total no brainer at this point don't you think? I accept that it's quite a dramatic change and that certain pollies will need to be against it before they get a sense of the temperature but here's hoping the multiple real world examples of it being a success count for something.
Rukh
Posts: 1121
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Make it subject to similar restrictions as smoking cigarettes (in terms of where you can't do it to avoid second hand smoke etc.) and realistic/scientifically backed restrictions similar to alcohol (for things like driving) then yeah, should tote(lly) (heh) be legal.
infi
Posts: 24062
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

I just bought into a legal weed farm in Queensland. Let's hope for a 40 bagger.

Cann Group is about to be taken over for $500m.
Nmag
Posts: 993
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

ABC news website:

South Korean President Moon Jae-in reckons Donald Trump should get a peace prize for trying to end the standoff with North Korea over its nuclear weapons program.


Story sits at bottom of all other stories at 5:30 pm peak time. Story is not about "why" South Korean President Moon Jae-in reckons Donald Trump should get a peace prize for trying to end the standoff with North Korea over its nuclear weapons program, but instead about wether Trump could actually be in the running to get one. Well nice left wing play there ABC.

I think the important part in the wall of text they wrote is:

South Korean President Moon Jae-in reckons Donald Trump should get a peace prize for trying to end the standoff with North Korea over its nuclear weapons program.


These perceptions seem to conflict with the vibe of ABC's story covering Trumps remarks last week about helping out with the NK conflict. Maybe if they asked South Korean President Moon Jae-in for his thoughts before vomiting their left wing bias TDS rubbish, they might be reporting the news more 'accurately' and bias free. It's a concern. Tax payers pay for the junk that comes out of the ABC. If you follow some of the ABC facebook pages, you really start to wonder WTF these people think they are, to push an agenda that is more left than our population votes.

We won't see this on Media Watch, because, they too exhibit bias.
Vash
Posts: 5778
Location:


Seems like more people are left leaning than you think Nmag.

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/strong-support-for-free-health-education-and-for-taxing-rich-more-poll-20180502-p4zcsj.html


infi
Posts: 24063
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

people don't want to pay for stuff and tax the rich instead, i am stunned!
dazedandconfused
Posts: 608
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Seems like more people are left leaning than you think Nmag.

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/strong-support-for-free-health-education-and-for-taxing-rich-more-poll-20180502-p4zcsj.html




If you take anything from that article other than people generally don't know what they are talking about then I don't know what to tell you. The level of self-contradiction in those statistics is mind boggling.
Jim
Posts: 13751
Location: UK


Seems like more people are left leaning than you think Nmag.

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/strong-support-for-free-health-education-and-for-taxing-rich-more-poll-20180502-p4zcsj.html




This comment doesn't follow from nmag's - he said "push an agenda that is more left than our population votes", which doesn't make any claim as to how many people are left-leaning, it only states that the abc push an agenda which is further left than the population votes - which is demonstrably true.

To spell it out simply: if you had 99% of the population voting slightly left of centre for example, nmag's statement could still be true if the abc's general agenda was substantially further left than those voters
PornoPete
Posts: 3176
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

, it only states that the abc push an agenda which is further left than the population votes - which is demonstrably true.


Spoken like a Russian bot Jim. If that is your real handle.
infi
Posts: 24064
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Jim's programming has definitely changed lately.
Nmag
Posts: 994
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Seems like more people are left leaning than you think Nmag.

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/strong-support-for-free-health-education-and-for-taxing-rich-more-poll-20180502-p4zcsj.html




Vash, that's beyond dumb.
Jim
Posts: 13752
Location: UK

каждый по своим потребностям, но от каждого по способностям
PornoPete
Posts: 3177
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Soixante-Huitard
Viper119
Posts: 3386
Location: Other International

I came across this dashboard for 'monitoring Russian influence activity on Twitter': https://dashboard.securingdemocracy.org/ which I thought was interesting. This is also a interesting tool: https://botcheck.me/

I also saw somewhere that Twitter had updated their Russian propaganda linked bot count to around 50,000. Facebook had a couple hundred accounts it closed as they were Russian linked.

And the largest Black Lives Matter page on FB was a scam being run by some Australians!? The largest Black Lives Matter page on Facebook was a scam

I'm not sure we can be so sure that internet propaganda scamming isn't having an effect? Perhaps not as great an effect as some allude to I suppose.

Then in other news I was reading this about Macron today, seems like he might just be getting on a positive track! Measuring Macron - Is France’s leader rebooting the economy?

If Macron does well, might it (a new moderate centre party) become a viable model for the UK, Aus and maybe even the US? Hard to imagine in the US but I could see it in the UK (the Lib Dems were kind of that before they got demolished). Not sure about Aus.
PornoPete
Posts: 3178
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I'm not sure we can be so sure that internet propaganda scamming isn't having an effect? Perhaps not as great an effect as some allude to I suppose.


But what is the effect? Seems to me the odds of someone who buys the Russian bot theory being an unthinking tribal moron go way up. Look at the people who use the term in this thread.

If you've seen the actual content and still believe, it removes all doubt. If you look at the ads Russia placed and think it changed someone's vote for either Trump, or Bernie I might add, you are without a shadow of doubt a tribal idiot who receives propaganda in place of newsand are too dumb to know it.

You stand a better than 80% chance of thinking people who watch fox news are idiots while uncritically reading the guardian.
the prosecution rests
Spook
Posts: 41080
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
lols, that blacklivesmatter facey page sounded like it could have been a nice little earner!
Nmag
Posts: 995
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Dear Mr Minista,

We the peeps charged with the responsibility to provide service do not like transparency or being held to account for the effectiveness of the services we provide. Facts are dangerous boss.

Labor's education spokesman Jihad Dib, former principal of Punchbowl Boys School, is in support of Mr Stokes' call and said the test had put enormous pressure on families.


It is also providing transparency regarding comparative performance regarding our rich cultural diversities. My fellow communist and socialist supporters also oppose this because facts are dangerous.

not useful as it did not take into account any differences between different schools and communities


People who I identity with are getting a raw deal from this transparency. Facts are bad mkay. Also, we found some kids are getting an advantage because their parents give a crap enough to try and make up for the ineffectiveness of the services we provide. Please stop the transparency and the facts.

Labor's education spokesman Jihad Dib, former principal of Punchbowl Boys School, is in support of Mr Stokes' call and said the test had put enormous pressure on families. "Because of the high stakes nature of it, the tutoring industry has absolutely exploded," he said. "I know stories where parents are working two or three jobs just to pay for their kids to get tutoring. "And kids as young as nine are not getting put into weekend sports just so they can go to cram schools or tutoring centres."
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-05-04/demands-for-naplan-to-be-dumped-in-nsw/9725934

https://i.imgur.com/gF411mk.jpg
Jim
Posts: 13753
Location: UK

I wish more news outlets were like https://www.theknifemedia.com/
PornoPete
Posts: 3179
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

It'd be nicer if the knife didn't have to exist and you could rely on people who call themselves journalists to do what it says on the tin.
Jim
Posts: 13754
Location: UK

hah :(
infi
Posts: 24065
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

great site, Jim.
Viper119
Posts: 3387
Location: Other International

I get your point there Pete, but from what I've seen it has had some real world effect. I came across these the other night which they're linking as precursors to the supposed election meddling.

Hysteria over Jade Helm exercise in Texas was fueled by Russians, former CIA director says

A former director of the CIA and NSA said Wednesday that hysteria in Texas over a 2015 U.S. military training exercise called Jade Helm was fueled by Russians wanting to dominate “the information space,” and that Texas Gov. Greg Abbott's decision to send the Texas State Guard to monitor the operation gave them proof of the power of such misinformation campaigns.

Michael Hayden, speaking on MSNBC’s Morning Joe podcast, chalked up peoples’ fear over Jade Helm 15 to “Russian bots and the American alt-right media [that] convinced many Texans [Jade Helm] was an Obama plan to round up political dissidents.”

Abbott ordered the State Guard to monitor the federal exercise soon after news broke of the operation. Hayden said that move gave Russians the go-ahead to continue — and possibly expand — their efforts to spread fear.


And, A Russian Facebook page organized a protest in Texas. A different Russian page launched the counterprotest.

Last year, two Russian Facebook pages organized dueling rallies in front of the Islamic Da’wah Center of Houston, according to information released by U.S. Sen. Richard Burr, a North Carolina Republican.

Heart of Texas, a Russian-controlled Facebook group that promoted Texas secession, leaned into an image of the state as a land of guns and barbecue and amassed hundreds of thousands of followers. One of their ads on Facebook announced a noon rally on May 21, 2016 to “Stop Islamification of Texas.”

A separate Russian-sponsored group, United Muslims of America, advertised a “Save Islamic Knowledge” rally for the same place and time.
fpot
Posts: 26381
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

There's two reasons to downplay the influence of Russian operatives on social media. If you're in panicky denial mode because you're slowly realising the talking points you've been frothing about for years are all based on a lie, or you're in on the scam. What I mean by that is that you're happy with the discord they're sowing because if it helps hard-right political figures get into power it can only be a good thing.

edit: imagine for a second it turns out that it isn't the Russian but instead a rogue AI of unknown origin posing as Russian operatives!@@@! That protest and counter-protest is totally something an AI would do.
PornoPete
Posts: 3180
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Yeah ok but I reiterate my question what is the effect?

Russia pouring fuel on a pre-existing dumpster fire doesn't seem to me to say much of anything of the actual underlying causes of division.

People don't need much help in that department.

Moreover, the example you provide is a perfect example of why the Russian business is overblown and people who tout it fall into one of two categories.

The Russians don't give a toss about Trump or Clinton. They want to hurt America. That's it. That's the whole motive. And there is a hundred year history of form on that. the evidence you provide neatly demonstrates this. The goal is chaos.

Therefore if you really believe it swayed the election you are a useful idiot. The outrage about Hillary being robbed was and is the point.

But let's not kid ourselves that most left-leaning people haven't managed to convince themselves the US has elected literally Hitler and stands on the precipice of a descent into fascism, quite independently of any Russian help.

That's category 1.

Category 2 know what I'm saying is true and are willing to exploit it anyway.

Do you think the Democrats aren't loving every second of Mueller? I'll say it again he is not going to show collusion.

But they'll pour fuel on that all the way to November anyway.

The point is that Russia is at best a distraction from much bigger and deeper problems which are driving the zeitgeist. For example, an interesting question to do with Russia might be: isn't interesting it happened in conjunction with the rise activist clickbait s***rags like vox?

/Edit/ see fpots post viper. I rest my f***ing case. He's so f***ing dumb he doesn't realise Russian bots pump out his talking points too. God damn, I'm good.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39589
Location: Other International

In more important news, I have often wondered why craft beer was so expensive
fpot
Posts: 26382
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

In future news, craft beer brewers keep prices the same because only s*** beer decreases in value.
PornoPete
Posts: 3181
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I thought I might give a better example for you Viper. or at least a more concrete one.

This is Michael Moore

http://thehill.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumb_small_article/public/blogs/michaelmoore_0.jpg?itok=N5JHP1Wp

He is a fat, lying, hypocritical propagandist.

Michy hates capitalism. This is Michy's million dollar home.

https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/NiGCX3RL9Nx7cQYwnlAATgrSEq8=/0x600/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/4471725/MM26.0.jpg

Michael Moore was a pioneer of the "the spirit of the book is true" (ie the defence of fire and fury being essentially fact-free) "documentary" making.

This Is Michael Moore out the front of trump tower looking sad and making a banal uniformed point about immigration (but I think we both know he's sad cause they ran out of taco bowls).

https://cdn.newsday.com/polopoly_fs/1.11242949.1450452716!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_768/image.jpg

Michael Moore received universal praise for his letter which accompanied that photo. His letter does not engage with a single one of the policy issues that the temporary travel ban was put in place to deal with or how they might better be addressed. It waxes lyrical about the nation of immigrants platitudes that we have all heard from the usual suspects for over a decade now. It refuses to accept there may actually be hard choices in immigration policy and happily calls anyone who disagrees racist.

This is Micheal Moore at a rally organised by Russians.

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/newpix/2018/02/20/16/4968383B00000578-5413699-image-m-13_1519142788004.jpg

Do you think fpot, vash, phooks, trog or anyone even vaguely left-leaning will ever say this

What I mean by that is that you're happy with the discord they're sowing because if it helps hard-right political figures get into power it can only be a good thing.


about his participation in that rally? Or do you think some sort of Moore discusses real issues apologia would be the outcome? Even more interesting do you think it is an important fact that Russians organised the rally he attended? if so why? My thoughts are Moore is a fat lying hypocritical propagandist who'd be saying his bulls*** to anyone who'll listen regardless of who organised and that is the real problem.

Is it possible (or insert iron clad certainty) that his brand of activism (the don't include facts which hurt your plea [or generally for that matter] to emotion kind) takes a lions share of responsibility for the current political climate? Could it be that 18 long years of calling Republicans inhuman monsters may have just had a little bit more to do with election of someone who doesn't care if you call him racist or sexist than 16 Russians (the grand total Mueller was able to indict after 18 months of investigation) who'll never see the inside of a courtroom? I'm just spit ballin here.
infi
Posts: 24066
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

It's because he really cares.
fpot
Posts: 26384
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

One thing I am sure we can all agree on in regards to the Russian collusion thing is that trump seems incredibly resistant to blackmail. Russian intelligence would probably have a tough time getting to such a brilliant man so that's one point for the trump is clean crew I guess!
PornoPete
Posts: 3182
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

It's because he really cares.


I'd be disappointed too. I hear the taco bowls at Trump Tower really are very good.
Nmag
Posts: 996
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

When you sell media it's good to introduce as a much controversy as possible. You can have a panel of global experts, and the media will find opposition to the panel and give the minority opinion a disproportionate amount of air time, in the minorities favour. Media love minorities.

"Here we have Mr Tool from outback Australia who says Trump looked at him funny one day through the TV. Mr Tool says..." blah blah 3 paragraphs.
PornoPete
Posts: 3183
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Mueller's crack team of crack prosecutors known for cracking skills have asked for a 6 week adjournment because they claim they failed to serve process on a company correctly who was in court to hear the request for the adjournment.

The point of service is to alert the other side they have to attend court. Nothing says slam dunk prosecution like saying you need 6 weeks to tell the person standing beside you court they need to attend court.
funky
Posts: 1931
Location: Canada
isn't the knife media a sort of front for/allied with that NXIVM cult? I had a quick look at that site and it reminded me of an article i read, after a re-google of things i think this is the article i found when i was randomly reading on NXIVM -https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2017/05/the-knife-of-aristotle-isnt-just-a-fake-fake-news.html, another i found - https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/987715294377533440.html

a quick googling suggests that at least some of the people listed on the knife media's staff page are connected to NXIVM / Keith Raniere - http://ivynevares.com/about/

no idea how credible this guy is (or the other sites, to be honest, but there does seem to be some defined links with screenshots etc), but his website seems dedicated to Raniere/NXIVM and he connects a bunch of the Knife media people to being NXIVM coaches - https://frankreport.com/2016/02/06/media-watchdog-knife-of-aristotle-filled-with-nxivm-coaches/

anyway, the mention of that site pinged my memory so i thought i'd check it out again, interesting that it portrays itself as a site to cut through the slant but also appears to be populated with people with people associated with an indicted sex cult. interesting!
dazedandconfused
Posts: 609
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

What happens when technocrats get it wrong? Apparently meaningless death which makes sense with all the Mao-lovers around here lol
Nmag
Posts: 997
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


My review of ABC news today.

At about 9:30 am this morning this headline on http://www.abc.net.au/news/

"Donald Trump may have put the Middle East on a path to disaster"

was

"Donald Trump has put the Middle East on a path to disaster"

So I read it, and the detail was like "If this happens, then this might happen, and if that does happen, this might happen, and if that happen, there is a chance of this other thing happening, which could put the Middle East on a path to disaster"

Even professional journalists suffer TDS, rage with a blurt, and then wind it back as it seems like gross exaggeration, scare mongering and clearly politically biased.

Iran deal: Donald Trump may have put the Middle East on a path to disaster By Middle East Correspondent Matt Brown Updated about an hour ago
Quoted at 6pm.

In better news, written by the obviously communist and socialist Guardian:

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/may/08/abc-funding-slashed-by-84m-in-budget-to-help-broadcaster-live-within-their-means

Hooraayyyy! ABC cut by $84m
Eorl
AusGamers Editor
Posts: 14889
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

We are outraged that the ABC are not being biased and saying we, the Liberal government are the best that Australia has ever seen and that Turnbull does not actually poo. Despicable scum need to be taught a lesson despite the huge amount of positives that ABC has through national home grown comedy, music and arts schemes and the amount of equal ground journalism conducted on a say in day out basis.

But also here Foxtel have $30M last year because we know you love rimming us hard.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7853
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
^ Agree with everything except for the non bias journalism. I watch the Drum most nights and the bias is sickening.
Nmag
Posts: 998
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

JJJ staff work hard at filling as much air time as possible with articles centred on the concerns of left wing voters. Did you miss the "Move the date" campaign for the JJJ Top 100? My understanding is they justified it by "polling their listeners".
Vash
Posts: 5779
Location:

Reality has a left wing bias
PornoPete
Posts: 3184
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Reality has a left wing bias


Jesus that is one of the dumbest quotes of all time.

The ABC's coverage of pulling out of the Iran deal has been a joke. There has been no analysis at all of the major faults with the deal (a big one being it doesn't stop them getting nukes it just slows them down). They just talk about how the US is isolated now. That's a laugh.

You watch the Euro's change their tune when their companies start getting hit with sanctions.

The idea that Trump could have put the middle east a path to war is pretty funny by pulling out of the deal. As contrasted with what exactly? that stuff going on in Syria seems a bit like a war.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39590
Location: Other International

^ Agree with everything except for the non bias journalism. I watch the Drum most nights and the bias is sickening.
what do you think their bias is towards?
Nmag
Posts: 999
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


They are clearly biased to the left.

This weeks assessment:

ABC has been particularly a-political in the last few days. Good work ABC.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-05-14/naplan-tests-are-valuable-and-cis-report-backs-testing/9757552

Their article today, regarding this report, appears to conflict with some of the rubbish ABC has been giving air to. Rubbish that would agree with public sector education union... the teachers who don't like transparency and facts.


Raven
Posts: 9599
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
Biased? Or is that just the way same grounding ends up being?
fpot
Posts: 26390
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

lol Israeli security forces murdered dozens of people and the stance of the totally not fascist US government is that it was the murdered people's fault.
PornoPete
Posts: 3185
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

lol Israeli security forces murdered dozens of people and the stance of the totally not fascist US government is that it was the murdered people's fault.


Lol that's like totes definitely what happened and fpot is definitely not providing an anti-insight. Must have been while Israel was treating people like chattel in their concentration camps trying to raise satan with child sacrifices and re-introducing jim crow on brown people.

I heard also that they give Palestinians aids by clawing out their eyes and getting aids infected zombies to piss in the empty sockets. That was article 5 of the skyes picot accord which fpot definitely knows exists and its role in the middle east.

Lol, I'm politically engaged like fpot.
fpot
Posts: 26391
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

And like, the President of the United States hasn't even mentioned it even though he's partly responsible. Instead he's whining about fake news and congratulating Israel on their big day. Welcome to 2018 mother f***ers. And unless that wretched waste of life above me there is apologising for being such an obtuse little dick and begging forgiveness for how he could be so f***ing stupid, there's an army of people, some real some not, willing to defend him no matter what he does or what he says. He is a god who can do no wrong.
PornoPete
Posts: 3186
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I know right. I'm so politically informed I know moving an embassy is the "cause" the people innocenly throwing Molotov cocktails and launching rockets at Israeli civilians and soliders for five weeks. That's a valid use of the word "cause" for totes reals. Hamas didn't cause anything by threating to tear down a border fence and kill everyone. It was Trump. I've noticed a strange rash around my a****** recently. Probs Trump caused it in a tots fash move.

I'm so good at spotting fascists I know that the fascists definitely Arent the Hamas acolytes literally flying Nazi flags. It's definitely the person who won his election (and definitely not to the group violently disposing of the PA in Gaza openly committed to the genocide of all jews, and who are unable to provide drinking water but mysteriously always have money for rockets to launch at Jews.)

Look at how good I am at political. Way better than you chattel jim crow owning sons of bitches who lack any self awareness.

I'm like totes informed. I read it in the guardian and vox. Then I saw a Russian bot disagree with me only further proving my knowing of the politics is perfect.

Haha post limit increased. Still worth it. Fpot gets sad when you point out his vacuous non-opinions are vacuous non-opinions. To the person who limited me. Feel free to step through why I should be post limited for pointing out saying Trump is responsible for "murdered" Palestinians is a profoundly stupid thing to say. It's is a sad excuse for thought and respresents the nub of the current political climate, my tone echos his for that reason. It should be stridently paid out. You're welcome.
infi
Posts: 24068
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

that was woke af
PornoPete
Posts: 3187
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Turns out talking to fpot like he talks to everyone else is one of fpots buttons.
Raven
Posts: 9600
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
lol Israeli security forces murdered dozens of people and the stance of the totally not fascist US government is that it was the murdered people's fault.


I know, right. I should totally be able to start a riot on the border with modified flags bearing the swastika, and fly kites over the line of soldiers to drop explosives on to them, and expect to not get shot. It's completely unreasonable for explosives to be retaliated to with bullets.
PornoPete
Posts: 3188
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Careful Raven.

You've clearly been listening to Russian bots to express such an opinion.
fpot
Posts: 26393
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I know, right. I should totally be able to start a riot on the border with modified flags bearing the swastika, and fly kites over the line of soldiers to drop explosives on to them, and expect to not get shot. It's completely unreasonable for explosives to be retaliated to with bullets.
If I were to use this argument I'd want to be pretty certain that the 58 killed and 2700 wounded were all a serious threat to elite soldiers, otherwise I'd be running the risk of supporting the literal slaughter of dozens and the indiscriminate wounding of thousands of people.
PornoPete
Posts: 3189
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

If I were to use this argument I'd want to be pretty certain that the 58 killed and 2700 wounded were all a serious threat to elite soldiers, otherwise I'd be running the risk of supporting the literal slaughter of dozens and the indiscriminate wounding of thousands of people.


Wow.

There will be no context around that baldfaced stupidity.

Don't expect to see the number of protesters in attendance or how many people were shot, as opposed to injured by exposure to tear gas any of that.

The picture quite deliberately being painted and diametrically opposed to reality is Isreali soliders went on a cold blooded killing spree.

Oh and it's trumps fault that they did.
Vash
Posts: 5780
Location:

I wonder how many of those 1400 injured were using explosives.

edit: is it 2700 now? :/
Spook
Posts: 41084
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
good to see Tone now wants Australia to move its embassy to the big J.
fpot
Posts: 26394
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

He knows his audience.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7854
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
guys guys! what would happen if Hamas stopped being terrorist karnts and a publically elected government allowed the Palestinians to accept the two state solution?
PornoPete
Posts: 3190
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Turnbull is laying the blame on Hamas.

Julie Bishop and bill shorten have said Isreal has an unequivocal right to defend itself.

I'm sure they were informed by the alt right as well. Or Russian bots.

It's almost like fpot is wrong. Again.


Slaps. Nothing would happen because Isreal us the root of all evil according to someone who like really hates Nazis
Vash
Posts: 5781
Location:

guys guys! what would happen if Hamas stopped being terrorist karnts and a publically elected government allowed the Palestinians to accept the two state solution?


What if the people of Palestine don't want that, and would prefer to have some of their land back?

Im sure we've all seen this.

https://i.imgur.com/bJyIuam.jpg
PornoPete
Posts: 3191
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Vash will be able to tell you who made that map and the significance of 1949 and 1968.

He'll be able to tell you when he says they want "their" land back who governed the entire area on that map prior to 1948.

He'll be able to tell you who rejected the deal for Jerusalem to be an internationally governed city state.

He'll be able to say who keeps rejecting peace deals. He'll be able to tell you all this from his own extensive knowledge of the history of the conflict.

He isn't posting BDS propaganda memes because the were posted on a socialist alliance Facebook feed.
Nmag
Posts: 1000
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Pull everyone out of the middle east. Give Israel the option to form a new place in USA somewhere. They can take their wall and even a mountain if necessary. It can be done.

Some will move, some will stay. Then let the region sort itself out. I'd stand well back while this happens. Puts some bets on centre bet and watch it play out.

Make sure most the worlds journalists go over there to get close to the action for the best footage of the mass carnage that will eventually lead to world peace.

The USA economy might not cope without enough war though.
Vash
Posts: 5782
Location:

Give Israel the option to form a new place in USA somewhere.


lol
PornoPete
Posts: 3192
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

If I were to use this argument I'd want to be pretty certain that the 58 killed and 2700 wounded were all a serious threat to elite soldiers, otherwise I'd be running the risk of supporting the literal slaughter of dozens and the indiscriminate wounding of thousands of people.


Hamas now claiming at least 10 of those killed were members of their interior ministry. link

If I was to claim the IDF was murdering people at Trumps behest I'd want to be sure what was obviously a terrorist run riot at a border with an express goal of causing innocent casualties wasn't that. Otherwise I'd run the risk of obscenely grandstanding on the dead to virtue signal about Trump.

So dear admins. Now that fpot is indisputably factually wrong and baselessly accusing people of the most repulsive crimes and has demonstrated he is willing to stand on the bodies of those killed to take a factually wrong swipe at Trump I look forward to a similar post limit being implemented on him and mine being lifted.
funky
Posts: 1932
Location: Canada
Interestingly NMag, that was sort of a proposal in the 40's - Slattery Report - Jewish European Refugees to Alaska

last edited by funky at 09:15:15 16/May/18
Raven
Posts: 9601
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
I mean we could probably do the same and give them a nice chunk of land in the Northern Territory if we really wanted - problem is, they don't want to, both sides are f***ing bats*** crazy and see it as some kind of religious right to be specifically there, so they'll never go for it.
fpot
Posts: 26396
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

This is why you congratulate yourself after a thing has happened, and not before.

Bonus video -

dazedandconfused
Posts: 610
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

With all this talk of historical land rights, I think it pertinent to demand the return of Istanbul to the Glorious Holy Roman Empire. #MakeIstanbulConstantinopleAgain
fpot
Posts: 26397
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Nice strawman.
Raven
Posts: 9602
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
With all this talk of historical land rights, I think it pertinent to demand the return of Istanbul to the Glorious Holy Roman Empire. #MakeIstanbulConstantinopleAgain


Pft, what about Mauritania, Gaul, even Britania? Hadrian drew a line in the sand and the Northen brits invaded while the empire needed protecting.
Nmag
Posts: 1001
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I think the Palestinians are rightly pissed off, and that out mainstream media tends to try and pull our heart strings for Israel. On this topic I'd say ABC and SBS are probably more objective with their reporting. Through our education system, mainstream media, documentaries, the entertainment industry, american movies, Hollywood.. we tend to get a flavour. It's almost as if the Jewish world has a great deal of influence over how these things are communicated. Some might regard it as "information warfare".

I recommend finding opposing views to mainstream and consider them. Watch a video of religion spreading and changing in Europe. It's like someone dumped the Jews right in the middle of the Muslim heartland, like trying to treat a continually expanding and contracting problem. They can both make religious claims about the land, but if we just agreed that there is no magical intervening being then the case of moving the Jews out is easy. Then they can claim they were there thousandths of year ago.. well stiff s***. I probbaly had decedents thousands of years ago in Europe and I'm not claiming that land under the banner of Atheism.
Raven
Posts: 9603
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
If they agreed there was no magical intervening being would they still be Jews? Hell, would there still be a need to move them out since there's no being for the other side to claim insists they be driven in to the ocean?
PornoPete
Posts: 3193
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

It's like someone dumped the Jews right in the middle of the Muslim heartland, like trying to treat a continually expanding and contracting problem.


Its nothing like that at all.

They can both make religious claims about the land, but if we just agreed that there is no magical intervening being then the case of moving the Jews out is easy.


No it isn't.

Then they can claim they were there thousandths of year ago.. well stiff s***


They don't claim that. They claim they have been there for thousands of years and they have. Jeruselum has had a continuous Jewish population for at least the last 5000 years. they've been in Jerusalem for nearly double the time Italians have been in Rome. the region more broadly probably more like 10,000 years. Not they were there and came back. They have been there the whole time. they have as strong a claim to the land as any people have to any land anywhere.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7855
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
My prophet is George Carlin.



PornoPete
Posts: 3194
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Here little dose of reality from the 2014 war in Gaza.

When Hamas’s leaders surveyed their assets before this summer’s round of fighting, they knew that among those assets was the international press. The AP staff in Gaza City would witness a rocket launch right beside their office, endangering reporters and other civilians nearby—and the AP wouldn’t report it, not even in AP articles about Israeli claims that Hamas was launching rockets from residential areas. (This happened.) Hamas fighters would burst into the AP’s Gaza bureau and threaten the staff—and the AP wouldn’t report it. (This also happened.) Cameramen waiting outside Shifa Hospital in Gaza City would film the arrival of civilian casualties and then, at a signal from an official, turn off their cameras when wounded and dead fighters came in, helping Hamas maintain the illusion that only civilians were dying. (This too happened; the information comes from multiple sources with firsthand knowledge of these incidents.)


There is simply no question Hamas routinely use human shields and attack civilian populations. It is their MO and has been from the start.

The idea the media biased in favour of Israel is nothing short of delusional. the AP didn't report Hamas rockets being fired beside their office while condemning Israel for falsely claiming they were responding to Hamas firing from civilian populated areas.

The idea that Hamas (or their supporters) are underdogs held down by an oppressor and they want a reasonable solution is also nothing short of delusional.

This coverage is the source of comments like this
If I were to use this argument I'd want to be pretty certain that the 58 killed and 2700 wounded were all a serious threat to elite soldiers,


Which is so dumb it's close to anti-thought.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 611
Location: Sydney, New South Wales



What if the people of Palestine don't want that, and would prefer to have some of their land back?

Im sure we've all seen this.

https://i.imgur.com/bJyIuam.jpg
http://www.winnipegjewishreview.com/userFiles/images/img2_3866.jpg

See how pretty maps are meaningless when you fail to understand history and its context?
Nmag
Posts: 1002
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I think we are seeing exaggeration from both sides of the argument. I believe most of this statement:

The Land of Israel has come under the sway of various empires and has been home to a variety of ethnicities, but was predominantly Jewish from roughly 1,000 years before the Common Era (BCE) until the 3rd century of the Common Era (CE).[1] The adoption of Christianity by the Roman Empire in the 4th century led to a Greco-Roman Christian majority which lasted until the 7th century when the area was conquered by the Arab Muslim Empires. It gradually became predominantly Moslem until the Crusades between 1096 and 1291, when it was the focal point of conflict between Christianity and Islam. From the 13th century it was mainly Moslem with Arabic as the dominant language and was first part of the Syrian province of the Mamluk Sultanate and then part of the Ottoman Empire until the British conquest in 1917. A Jewish national movement, Zionism, emerged in the late-19th century (partially in response to growing anti-Semitism) and Aliyah (Jewish immigration to the Land of Israel) increased. After World War I, Ottoman territories in the Levant came under British and French control and the League of Nations granted the British a Mandate to rule Palestine which was to be turned into a Jewish National Home. A rival Arab nationalism also claimed rights over the former Ottoman territories and sought to prevent Jewish migration into Palestine, leading to growing Arab–Jewish tensions. Israeli independence in 1948 was marked by massive migration of Jews from Europe, a Jewish exodus from Arab and Muslim countries to Israel, and of Arabs from Israel, followed by the Arab–Israeli conflict.[2] About 43% of the world's Jews live in Israel today, the largest Jewish community in the world.[


1000 BC - 300 AD predominately Jewish. That's ancient history. In our modern history, like in the last 100 years the Jews flocked there after Israel being formed.

Watch the video of religion pulsing and shifting around Europe, and tell me again how dumb I am for stating it's like Israel was set up right in the middle of Muslim heart land. We haven't even got to oil yet, we still just on religion. Israel is an aggressive strategic outpost for the West.

https://youtu.be/AvFl6UBZLv4
PornoPete
Posts: 3195
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Nmag there is a difference between predominantly Jewish, and a Jewish community being present, there are a few people in the bible before david. Jews have been a minority where ever they are for the vast majority of recorded history.

Archaeological evidence of Hebrew speaking people goes back at least 10000 in the areas in and around Israel. There has been a Jewish presence in Jersuleum since its founding in 3000 BCE. we are now in 2018 AD. You can run the numbers yourself.

Muslims had not controlled the land around Israel and Palestine for nearly 30 years prior to the formation of Israel. Local Muslims hadn't controlled the land for like 400 year before that, the Ottomans ruled it out of modern Turkey. The reason for Israel to exist is that Jews have been living there continuously for thousands of years, and the ottomans track record on the Jews was utterly wretched. even during mandate Palestine ethnic violence between jews and muslims/arabs was common. It is just not true that a bunch of jews were dumped on a bunch of unsuspecting Muslims in their "heartland" in a European "here you deal with it" scenario.

As for a wave of immigration after the formation of Israel, whats your point? The claim to the land doesn't stand or fall with that. But even if it was a point, remind me again why the Jews wanted to leave Europe after WW2. You managed to overlook all the Arab countries expelling jews as well. Where were they supposed to go?
fpot
Posts: 26399
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Today, in another totally not fascist move by the democratically elected US government, the President of the United States appointed Gina Haspel as CIA director. Gina Haspel is famous for torturing people to death and then destroying the evidence (but but but her destroyed torture tapes!).

People on twitter, some real some not, are saying it's a great decision. We need people in important places capable of being able to make the big decisions, like forcing food up someone's ass when they refuse to eat. It's for national security and I was just following orders.
PornoPete
Posts: 3196
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Oh I was confused. See when you celebrated North Korea pulling out of talks I thought you must like torture. Cause they do a s***load of it. I mean some people might think cheering a regime like that to score the most banal of points would make squealing like a stuck pig now abit hypocritical.

Some might also think the zero times you've ever mentioned extra judicial killing by drone strike authorised by the CIA under Obama might also makes this sudden concern about torture a bit hypocritical.

That's not the moral high ground you're standing on chum.
Nmag
Posts: 1003
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

in the last 100 years the Jews flocked there after Israel being formed


It's valid. You may have missed the video of the pulsing Muslim heartland with Israel plonked in the middle of it.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7856
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Equality of ....

fpot
Posts: 26400
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I've seen this Jordan Peterson pop up on certain twitters. Seems to be the darling of insufferable red pilled virgins from what I can see.

And another school shooting in the US. Some white guy. Probably some incel angry because a girl said no to him. Probably a big fan of trump. Business as usual.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7857
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
^ completely wrong

His whole point is he encourages free speech based on facts. Not this red/blue pill, right vs left identity politics bulls***.

He has been adopted by some right wing nutter utube channels but if you have a broad look at his other comments he doesn't identify with any real group and uses facts based on research to form his independent views.

He rips this bitch a new one when she tries to pigeon hole him.





last edited by sLaps_Forehead at 13:20:52 19/May/18
fpot
Posts: 26401
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Sure it is.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7858
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
More pigeonhole ripping

fpot
Posts: 26402
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I don't think anyone watches your dumb videos mate.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7859
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
^ Really, come on mate
fpot
Posts: 26403
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

If you go to the effort of typing a brief description in the most non-bias terms possible people might. No description no click is a policy I hold and I'm sure others do too.

I just saw your edit on the first dumb video. It's obvious you get very excited when a bitch gets told what's what. Completely normal behaviour you seem very well adjusted.
Vash
Posts: 5783
Location:

That second video doesn't seem like he ripped into her at all. Peterson seems to promote a way of thinking that if you're not successful academically then you're a failure at life. He basically comes down to, life is hard, dont worry about the wordly problems and just work on cleaning your room.
PornoPete
Posts: 3197
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

^ Really, come on mate
.

Did you honestly expect any different.


I just saw your edit on the first dumb video. It's obvious you get very excited when a bitch gets told what's what. Completely normal behaviour you seem very well adjusted.


Look at how long it took to default to "you don't agree with me therefore you are a bigot".

Is there some compelling reason fpot doesn't get consistently banned and nuked?

This is as deep as he ever goes.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7860
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
fpot is the forum PC Principal. I'm glad he's here to put me in my place... I was getting out of control.

Peterson seems to promote a way of thinking that if you're not successful academically then you're a failure at life.


Interesting opinion Vash, I didn't get that impression at all.
Nmag
Posts: 1004
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

fpot is easily triggered. He has nightmares about Donald Trump coming to the Gold Coast to get him whens he's sleep.

It could be attributed to confirmation bias and an inability to recognise that a lot of journalists and the entertainment industry who deliver his Trump-hate-news-feeds have more reason to hate on Trump than fpot does. It sells papers, and journalists and the entertainment industry can earn credibility and money easily by going with the Trump hate angle on a naive market that want more trump hate articles.
fpot
Posts: 26404
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

The irony of being deemed 'triggered' by a ponce so fragile that he's up to his third, fourth, fifth, tenth account is not lost on me. Brave enough to say who you really are yet or are you still building up to it?
Jim
Posts: 13755
Location:

That second video doesn't seem like he ripped into her at all. Peterson seems to promote a way of thinking that if you're not successful academically then you're a failure at life. He basically comes down to, life is hard, dont worry about the wordly problems and just work on cleaning your room.


Sure, if the only thing you bothered to read or view about Jordan Peterson were disingenuous or ignorant hit pieces. Jordan Peterson has plenty of flaws but what leftists claim they are, usually aint one of them.



And those types of videos are usually ridiculous because instead of showing context and allowing the nuances of an issue to be shown to the viewer, they show short snips that probably just somehow gratified the bias of the video creator. They are generally anti-intellectual wastes of time, probably even clickbait for youtube views in a lot of cases.
PornoPete
Posts: 3198
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

fpot is the forum PC Principal. I'm glad he's here to put me in my place... I was getting out of control.


Aren't we all. If there is one thing I've taken from your posts it's how much you obviously hate women. I take it mostly from the aggressive typeset you use.

I just know deep down you prefer Helvetica and that means you are a nazi Russian bot who hates women.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7861
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Yes thank skydaddy for fpot!

He looked deep into my soul and diagnosed my mental deficiency. I'm now in therapy. I'll keep the forum posted with my progress!
PornoPete
Posts: 3199
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Yes you'll need three hail metoos, and four vivalaresistances.

You must wear a pussy hat for the next week to appease the vengeful and knowing fpot.
fpot
Posts: 26405
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Three posts and you're still talking about it. Sensitive much? I'm sorry for bringing it up mate I won't shame you for enjoying your bitches getting told videos anymore.
PornoPete
Posts: 3200
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Yeah slaps do you feel ashamed for failing to walk the highroad like fpot.

This fpot being mature.

All it is is fpot can flail around like an utter retard and if you object to his banal thoughtless insults you're immature.
fpot
Posts: 26406
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I have a honest question for parents on here - if you lived in the USA what would your thoughts be about the situation and what would your approach be if your kid went to an at risk school? I honestly don't know what I'd do, but I know what I'd think. I'd feel completely checkmated by it. While the NRA exists nothing will get done. If the gun problem isn't solved by this school shooting or maybe the next one in a couple of months then it proves (if it hasn't been already) that this is an insurmountable problem. I point out Parkland in particular because it was the first one where the victims were able to muster a voice and actually break through a little. Seemed new to me and for a second there I thought it might work. I feel this most recent (at time of typing) shooting is going to be spun in a way that makes their approach seem ineffective so MORE GUNS ARE NEEDED. The only thing to do is convert schools into fortresses and if you can find a better example of once hypothesized dystopia becoming real-life dystopia then be on the lookout for replicants.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7862
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I've given up on 'Merica with regards to guns. Guns are just so ingrained into their culture that I reckon there could be a massacre once a month and the NRA and gun nuts still would not give one millimetre of ground to rational Gun Control laws.

And then there is the issue of actually implementing gun control in a country of 350 million people and 270 million firearms.
PornoPete
Posts: 3201
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

and the NRA and gun nuts still would not give one millimetre of ground to rational Gun Control laws.


A starting position might be to recognise "gun nuts" are exercising a constitutionally enshrined right.

Another position to adopt might be to specifically say what "common sense gun control" looks like.

Yet another position might be recognise that the kids calling Marco Rubio a murderer who accepts Blood money makes for tv fpot can flick that bean to but is fundamentally dishonest and flatout counter productive.

After that town Hall and the utterly cynical "March for our lives" the NRA registered a surge in membership and polling for gun control started to swing toward the NRA position.

To make this point crystal clear. Fpot's thought that having school kids scream like, well children, at elected representatives would be effective was obviously retarded. It's demonstrably pushed changes to gun laws further away.

But I note he hasn't changed his attitude or approach. You might draw some uncharitable conclusions from that.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 612
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

If anti-gun zealots ever used some statistically backed arguments instead of a fanatical commitment to virtue signalling they might be considered. It has nothing to do with whether or not a 2nd Amendment organisation exists. Start by answering the question of gun crime in Chicago.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39592
Location: Other International

If anti-gun zealots
rhetoric to try to frame everyone that is anti-gun as a wild crazy haired hippy "zealot"
ever used some statistically backed arguments
attempt to use "science" to defend point while simultaneous not making one AND adding no evidence or data of their own
instead of a fanatical commitment to virtue signalling
attempt to re-frame the context of stopping school children getting shot as "virtue signalling", a phrase which you can attach to literally anything and of course is always negative, despite the fact that it's almost impossible to use the term objectively without virtue signalling of your own
they might be considered
you have to pretend and hand-wave pretty hard to ignore the vast volumes of insightful thought that has been published on this topic in the last few decades that carefully addresses all of these criteria and still have not been considered
It has nothing to do with whether or not a 2nd Amendment organisation exists
attempt to disregard one of the most interesting issues in the gun debate
Start by answering the question of gun crime in Chicago.
please ignore the massive problem of school shooting caused by easy access to guns and instead solve this other huge problem which is in no small way affected by easy access to guns

master class trolling
Raven
Posts: 9605
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
what would your approach be if your kid went to an at risk school?


What is considered an 'at risk' school? *Any* school?
fpot
Posts: 26407
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I thought about omitting the at risk part but I left it in because I assumed there'd be at least some schools in the USA that could be considered safe and that some parents might not actually need to worry about their kids being murdered on a daily basis.
PornoPete
Posts: 3202
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

attempt to re-frame the context of stopping school children getting shot as "virtue signalling", a phrase which you can attach to literally anything and of course is always negative, despite the fact that it's almost impossible to use the term objectively without virtue signalling of your own


Virtue Signalling is the act of public displays of loyalty to a given political point of view, with the goal of "signalling" your conformance with given groups political mores, rather than a good faith argument about complex moral issues. For example this in response to the slavish demonising the NRA.
attempt to disregard one of the most interesting issues in the gun debate


What is the most interesting part of the NRA's involvement exactly? the fact they are a useful shorthand for assigning blame for a complex problem? That is interesting, but I doubt it's what he meant.

attempt to use "science" to defend point while simultaneous not making one AND adding no evidence or data of their own
not engago in three two one

If trog engages at all, the response is going to include something like "it left a bad taste in my mouth arguing when there are dead kids", in a genuflection which definitely isn't this:

you have to pretend and hand-wave pretty hard to ignore the vast volumes of insightful thought that has been published on this topic in the last few decades that carefully addresses all of these criteria and still have not been considered


For example, it's going to be amazing when the fact the shooter in Texas wasn't legally able to buy the gun he used gets addressed. Which is definitely going to happen instead of a few posts of variations on won't someone think of the children.

instead solve this other huge problem which is in no small way affected by easy access to guns

There is definitely going to be some reflection about Chicago implementing gun control and how effective it was.

*edit*
fpot
Posts: 26408
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

attempt to re-frame the context of stopping school children getting shot as "virtue signalling"
It's pretty much a classic endgame argument for toxic bad faith arguers. Once every argument of theirs has been debunked, once every apologist road has been worn to the point it can no longer be walked they revert to the you're just pretending to care argument. It's at that point they break, because once that argument has been used there's no going back and they have to either admit they were wrong about something (which for them is impossible) or doggedly stick to it even though it's obviously not true. It's how trainwrecks of humanity are born.
PornoPete
Posts: 3203
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Once every argument of theirs has been debunked


Heh

not engago in three two one


See its when the "debunking" step gets routinely skipped, the odds of virtue signalling start increasing.
Nmag
Posts: 1005
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

fpot, the Americans have got serious issues. I think far worse than us. The gun issue is just an indication of what a messed up nation they are. Their pride demonstrated in their eagles, flags and general nationalism around their branding is evidence of how deluded and proud they are. They are very proud of their crap nation, and generally don't like outsiders providing guidance on how they might do things better. Many of them struggle with the concept that their nation is not as good as they try to brainwash themselves to believe.

Firearms
African american racial issues
Indigenous Indian issues
Sharing a border with Mexico
Their obsession with "Made in USA"
They like to do manufacturing, however are a little less accommodating of the shift to a global market where we buy "Made in China" more and more.
Obesity
Crime in general
Being involved in so many wars
Evangelism
Massive cars

I'm sure you could list some 'green' issues they have, and most likely comment on how they got into a situation where their President would be either be Sanders, another Clinton, or Donald Trump.

The place is bewildering.

To use a quote from an American tourist visiting overseas "Oh yeah the countries overseas were great, but so many immigrants"

So many of their issues come from refusing to realise they are more messed up than they think. Delusion.
Raven
Posts: 9606
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
It's so incredibly true. Many examples of it you can see without even having to go over there: Just look at any online forum. Reddit is a great example - anyone who tells an American that the way they do things has other better ways of being done gets downvoted to oblivion, on nearly any topic.

When you actually go there, it's a f***ing bizarre place. I can barely think of a time I've felt unsafe walking around anywhere in Melbourne late at night. Yet in the majority of cities I've visited in the US, it's very much a case of needing to be really cautious of everyone you come across.

Their obsession with nationalism is cult-like; their brainwashing with religion worse. As a foreigner you go to a hockey or basketball match and you suddenly wonder what the f*** you got in to, when it comes to the way they treat the national anthem and war vets. The latter is utterly insane in the way it comes up - you'd think they were gladiators of ancient times, with the way they're made out to be worshiped.

Don't get me started on cars and transport. The entitlement. Holy f***. The mere idea that anyone needs something of the ridiculous size and destructive power of an F250 for everyday use - why!? Oh right, because "freedom".
infi
Posts: 24069
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

risk management means taking reasonable steps to mitigate the risk. given the guns are going nowhere I would expect my child to be protected at the places she is in care.

I am very curious to hear a proposed gun control solution. the shooter used a shotgun and a revolver. no assault weapons involved.

America is born out of guns, guns are protected by the second amendment. controls such as backgrounds checks and licensing already exist. unless an amendment to the constitution occurs, nothing in the regulatory sphere will change this.

mass shootings are an american phenomenon due to their culture, not due to the guns. My personal view is the US is on the cutting edge of many late 20th/21st century issues: breakdown of the family, social media/fame/narcissism bug , internet's contribution to removal of real person interactions, have it now - inability to delay gratification, medication of society. There are so many "American" issues all converging on a young populace not yet equipped to handle the stress they are capable of causing.

Sapiens are used to leading a very slow existence which until the last 100 years was the case. Our latest technologies compound this anxious pressure exponentially. America is the epicentre of them. And guns like amplifiers on a sound stage make the small vibrations a millions times more powerful. The shootings are a symptom of a very sick national culture. Remember: black on black is the number one gun homicide category.

School shootings are a distinct phenomenon. The shooters want to exert power, they want to be famous, they feel powerless, isolated, rejected. Grab a gun and teach all the haters a lesson. I found Sandy Hook the saddest, what type of monster would you have to be to do that in a primary school. America is culturally and economically sinking.
Raven
Posts: 9607
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
I am very curious to hear a proposed gun control solution. the shooter used a shotgun and a revolver. no assault weapons involved.


Sure: Make gun sellers responsible for the actions and uses of any gun sold.

Who's going to want to sell a gun to someone they can't be 100% certain isn't going to use it for a legal purpose? It doesn't violate any 2nd amendment rights as you still have the right to own one - it's just someone needs to be willing to provide the firearm to begin with.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39594
Location: Other International

great post infi, I agree pretty much completely
Sure: Make gun sellers responsible for the actions and uses of any gun sold.
there are a zillion guns already out there, what would be the point?
fpot
Posts: 26410
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Sure: Make gun sellers responsible for the actions and uses of any gun sold. 
I really like this idea. Not saying it's problem free and ready to be implemented but it's good.
infi
Posts: 24070
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Sure: Make gun sellers responsible for the actions and uses of any gun sold.


Guess we make car dealers (or even second hand car sellers) responsible for DUI killers too.
fpot
Posts: 26411
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

You had to go and spoil your good post with a really s*** dumbism. Damn.
infi
Posts: 24071
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

You had to go and spoil your good post with a really s*** dumbism. Damn.


how so? if we are blaming the tools....
fpot
Posts: 26412
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

There's some fundamental differences between guns and cars you have forgotten to consider.
Viper119
Posts: 3388
Location: Other International

I get your points in the previous comments, Pete. I'm not sure I agree the 'it was already an issue the Russians are just adding to it' point negates the fact that these actions have been taken and they have had an effect, which is what you seemed to be refuting? I think the information wars topic is quite an interesting one and a real challenge for our future. State propaganda or political extremes aside, it can have real impact to society as a whole, no? Take the anti-vaxxer movement for example. I totes agree the election tampering outrage is hypocritical (and sensationalised), even existing issues aside, the US have been doing this s*** to everyone else for decades.

I agree with this:

My personal view is the US is on the cutting edge of many late 20th/21st century issues: breakdown of the family, social media/fame/narcissism bug , internet's contribution to removal of real person interactions, have it now - inability to delay gratification, medication of society. There are so many "American" issues all converging on a young populace not yet equipped to handle the stress they are capable of causing.


I think it goes deeper too, I think their blend of individualism & capitalism contributes to a lot of these, and other, socioeconomic issues. Like their incarceration rates & prison problems, healthcare, non-existent work benefits, deteriorating infrastructure, increasing poverty, etc.

I mean, there's plenty of other developed Western countries sitting on the same 20th/21st century nexus, but they don't seem to have quite as many deep-seeded issues as the US. Most of those countries seem to have more socialistic principles built into their societies than America does.

Also agree with this:

Their obsession with nationalism is cult-like; their brainwashing with religion worse.


I think their militarism has actually gotten pretty extreme when you think about it. Gotta support the troops! No matter what.

I don't know what I'd do re: fpots question. What could you do? Are there any safe schools? I feel like if you have enough money then you don't have any problems in America, but you need a lot of money. Sandyhook absolutely blew me away. America really is a very bizarre place, I've taken it off my 'places I'd live' list.
fpot
Posts: 26413
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland


https://imgur.com/dCVaboF.jpghttps://imgur.com/6OiWH3E.jpg

Completely normal. Same may describe it as slightly erratic. Now I wonder, I've noticed trump fans seem to be the calm rational types who think things through carefully. After reading this, do you think the next time they see a brown skinned person with a tattoo that they'll think hello fellow human being or dem's one of those animals mah president was talking about?

edit: and just in case like me you at first thought someone was taking the piss because surely he wouldn't double down like that - https://www.whitehouse.gov/articles/need-know-violent-animals-ms-13/
Raven
Posts: 9608
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
there are a zillion guns already out there, what would be the point?

Your response is pretty much a perfect example of why things will never improve: "Oh, but that only helps the situation from getting worse, it doesn't solve it. We'll only take a solution that will solve it completely, with no flaws at all".
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39595
Location: Other International

I don't think that idea stops it getting worse, I think it actively makes it /worse/, by setting a precedent where someone that is more or less totally detached from the problem and has almost no power to stop things happening is suddenly at the apex of responsibility.

I have a whole huge post I wrote for the other gun thread when this thing last happened 16 nanoseconds ago but it's on my other PC. It's mostly a collection of reasons why I think things will never improve, now that I think about it, but it does have some ideas.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 613
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I would argue the point trog but you like to hand out 10 hour post limits on people you disagree with. If you have a great way of making a point, waiting 10 hours while the argument has moved about 16 miles from where you left it, and then re-injecting yourself whilst somehow keeping the original context I'm all ears.

Meanwhile fpot makes posts like this

You had to go and spoil your good post with a really s*** dumbism. Damn.


and proceeds with impunity because he happens to follow the same fantasy ideology you do. What a sad sheltered little lefty bubble you live in. My theory is relatively confirmed that its not that lefties are bad people, its just that they don't have the intellectual courage or capacity to a) see why censorship is wrong and b) are too afraid to engage with people who disagree because they secretly know they haven't actually looked it up.
infi
Posts: 24072
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

I have a whole huge post I wrote for the other gun thread when this thing last happened 16 nanoseconds ago but it's on my other PC.


Get OneDrive ffs
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39596
Location: Other International

Get OneDrive ffs
yeh I have no idea why it's not in my Dropbox. I think it's because I write a lot of sensitive work stuff & don't like cloud-ifying it without encrypting it first so I default to keeping things locally.
PornoPete
Posts: 3204
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I get your points in the previous comments, Pete. I'm not sure I agree the 'it was already an issue the Russians are just adding to it' point negates the fact that these actions have been taken and they have had an effect, which is what you seemed to be refuting? I think the information wars topic is quite an interesting one and a real challenge for our future. State propaganda or political extremes aside, it can have real impact to society as a whole, no? Take the anti-vaxxer movement for example. I totes agree the election tampering outrage is hypocritical (and sensationalised), even existing issues p0aside, the US have been doing this s*** to everyone else for decades.


I am not disputing the Russian tried to do s***. I am disputing there was any effect worth discussing. I don't think there was for three reasons.

1 social media may have huge reach but it consistently polls terribly as a reliable news source (see pew attitudes in media series). There is no reason or at least very limited reason to suspect there is a broad effect in the information wars. to the contrary, the evidence suggests most people don't take social media seriously for political issues.

2 every example I've been shown has an alternative explanation grounded in garden-variety polarisation.

3 what would a solution that didn't trample legitimate expression look like.

Taken together there is a limited reason to accept there is an effect, much less an adequate description of what the effect is. The 3rd one is important. Really really important. Because all the social media companies run “trust and safety” policies that are f***ing useless. If we were to run off an start looking for Russian witches to censor, I'd want the evidence to pretty damn compelling. If the evidence was a mixed bag, I'd start looking more closely at the people asking for censorship.

I have no doubt Russia tried. I seriously doubt they had much success.

on a side point, I'm not sure the anti-vaxxer movement really does the work you want it to. They are a noisy but tiny minority. A quick google tells me Australian vaccination rates are generally in the 90% area and have been for ages. You can find communities with lower rates, but generally, nobody is listening to anti-vaxxers.

I might add there is an interesting meta point there with antivaxxers. Social media distorts perceptions in strange ways. Seemingly large numbers can get involved in stuff very quickly, but the numbers while they sound large can actually be pretty small when placed in their true context.

For example you might find a page on Facebook which has even hundreds of thousands of followers. Which sounds like a big number. And in some contexts it is. In the Facebook context it is close to immeasurably small.

I remember listening to a Ricky Gervais bit recently talking about how easy it is to get 100,000 signatures on a petition, and that being important because when a petition gets that many signatures it has to go before parliament.

He praises this as a positive development. But I'm less certain. My view is that if the 100,000 signatures have not come from UK residents I don't see a valid reason to chew up parliaments time with it.

My point is that pre social media 100,000 signatures was a significant number of signatures. Now it isn't and the bar for what should be considered significant should adjusted accordingly. More broadly the way in which we judge significance on hot button issues floating around social media needs to reflect this context properly.
Nmag
Posts: 1006
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

A photo of great leaders

http://www.abc.net.au/news/image/9141994-3x2-940x627.png
Sir Redhat
Posts: 2225
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Guess we make car dealers (or even second hand car sellers) responsible for DUI killers too.


I agree, why can cars go over 110kph?

There's some fundamental differences between guns and cars you have forgotten to consider.


Cars in the current way they are used are worse than guns, they kill way more people and contribute to obesity and other health issues.
Spook
Posts: 41086
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
still a necessity though matey.

how else do we get to the shops?
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39600
Location: Other International

fwiw I spent 4 years without a car in the US & UK and just walked or rode to the shops. Now I'm back in BNE I'm trying to only walk or ride but now I'm back to having a car and I'm still tempted to drive more often than I'd like. but shopping for two is pretty easy
Cars in the current way they are used are worse than guns, they kill way more people and contribute to obesity and other health issues.
... but yeh, the positive value of cars massively outweighs the negatives. not true of guns
Raven
Posts: 9610
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
fwiw I spent 4 years without a car in the US & UK and just walked or rode to the shops. Now I'm back in BNE I'm trying to only walk or ride but now I'm back to having a car and I'm still tempted to drive more often than I'd like. but shopping for two is pretty easy


I would drive a lot less than I do if I had someone to hold the dog while I went in to buy groceries. Also, the dog would get far more walks.
fpot
Posts: 26415
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Black NFL players who peacefully protest - bad, get out of the country.

White nazis who murder people - very fine people.

Another totally not fascist thing a democratically elected person said.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39601
Location: Other International


I would drive a lot less than I do if I had someone to hold the dog while I went in to buy groceries. Also, the dog would get far more walks.
UBER FOR DOG HOLDERS PATENT PENDING

edit: holy s*** I checked Twitter after making this post and this literally just popped up as the top item in my feed: https://techcrunch.com/2018/05/24/dog-sitting-startup-rover-just-raised-155m/?utm_source=tctwreshare&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Techcrunch+%28TechCrunch%29&sr_share=twitter
fpot
Posts: 26416
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Also ICE Department of Health and Human Services, the totally not fascist wing of the trump administration lost just under 1500 children. And people get stopped by Border Patrols and questioned for speaking Spanish. And a new trick racists pull on people who aren't white is to threaten to call the police or ICE on them for no reason in the hope I guess that the police either kill them or ICE deport them.

All in not fascist USA with its democratically elected president.

edit: sorry got a bit blame happy with ICE there. I'm sure they're a great organisation full of very fine people.
PornoPete
Posts: 3205
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Look at fpot go.

He just feels it so deep. you can see the furrows of legitimate worry on his face. It's what drives him to post as follows:

[Facist/nazi] + [insert current news item] + [racist] - [insight of any kind]
fpot
Posts: 26417
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Actually it was ICE. They abducted the children and then the DHHS lost them due to ineptitude.
PornoPete
Posts: 3206
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Actually it was ICE. They abducted the children and then the DHHS lost them due to ineptitude.


He's a sensitive lad our fpot. But gee he gets very worked up and sometimes confuses things. Like in this case, he has confused "abducted" with giving unaccompanied minors refugee resettlement visas and placing them with a sponsor and then losing track of them later.

Children who show up at the border by themselves are usually apprehended by Border Patrol agents or turn themselves in to customs officers at the Department of Homeland Security. Once they are processed, they are turned over to the custody of the Department of Health and Human Services’ refugee office. The office runs more than 100 shelters around the country where it houses children and provides care until they can be turned over to a sponsor while awaiting their immigration hearings.


That is like totes the same thing as "abduction". Trap for young players that one.
Raven
Posts: 9611
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
UBER FOR DOG HOLDERS PATENT PENDING

It's always amazed me that shopping centres don't offer both this and a secure service for bikes.

Hell, even if it was a paid service surely it would more than pay for itself in both fees and the business it brings to renters in the centre.
Spook
Posts: 41087
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
dogs dont really need to go to shopping centres?

they should stay at home.
Raven
Posts: 9612
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
Yes, but then people just end up driving there. I can either walk down there and take the dog for a walk, and drop in quickly to get groceries, or what ends up happening is you just drive there, because there's no reason to walk.

If I need to take the dog for a walk and only have time to do one thing, one has to miss out.
Spook
Posts: 41088
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
i walk my dog to aldi and the bottlo regularly and just tie her up out the front. but yer, i woudlnt do that at a shopping centre. i actively avoid going to shopping centres because they are so horrible.
Raven
Posts: 9613
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
I live in the kind of area where pets get stolen, so would never leave him unattended :(
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7863
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Dogs go missing all the time in Korea
Nmag
Posts: 1008
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-06-04/nbn-chief-blames-gamers-for-congestion/9832596

Online gamers have been called out by the head of the National Broadband Network as a major cause of congestion on the fixed wireless network.

Vash
Posts: 5785
Location:

Hah. what a joke. don't games use like next to no data?
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39604
Location: Other International

Hah. what a joke. don't games use like next to no data?
playing them, yes. downloading them, no
Vash
Posts: 5786
Location:

Couldn't see that being much of a strain compared to the amount of people using Youtube or Netflix.
Spook
Posts: 41095
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
free tommy robinson! (the football thug lawbreaker)

http://www.abc.net.au/mediawatch/transcripts/s4852297.htm
PornoPete
Posts: 3207
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Interesting the article doesn't go into what the court case was about.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39605
Location: Other International

Couldn't see that being much of a strain compared to the amount of people using Youtube or Netflix.
it depends entirely on how much youtube and how much netflix people in your area are trying to watch vs how many games they're trying to download

e.g., when a new GTA or something comes out on Steam, it will mean more bandwidth is consumed in the next few days by 'gamers'.

I generally agree that video streaming probably uses more on average - probably quite a bit more - but people need to remember the peaks for gaming traffic are huge, huge, huge, like way way more than they'd download in a normal day of streaming. Nothing on the Internet occurs in a vacuum - especially on fixed wireless, which is the tech they're talking about being affected here.

I don't know enough about wireless technology - it just seems to me like it's a bottleneck that can't be solved without hard quotas.
Nmag
Posts: 1009
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Another article today

NBN blaming 'gamers' for slow broadband contradicts its own online advice

"Believe it or not, some of the biggest online games use very little data while you're playing compared to streaming HD video or even high-fidelity audio." - NBN
http://www.abc.net.au/triplej/programs/hack/nbn-blaming-gamers-for-slow-speeds-contradicts-own-advice/9836492


Jim
Posts: 13757
Location:

Interesting the article doesn't go into what the court case was about.


^ reported for hate speech
PornoPete
Posts: 3208
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

^ reported for hate speech


Well quite.

Here is a much better take on the situation. It would be easier to take the Robinson was going to sink a trial angle seriously if the Police didn't wait for 10 years and over a 1000 victims to start laying charges.

Jim
Posts: 13758
Location:

Maajid Nawaz, darling of the alt-right and a nazi-sympathising stealer of babies lollipops, demonstrating internalised racism again.

Oh, and the patriarchy something something
Jim
Posts: 13759
Location:


http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-06-04/nbn-chief-blames-gamers-for-congestion/9832596




seems like he back-pedalled a bit when questioned more, at least according to the quotes in that article
PornoPete
Posts: 3209
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

lollipops


They always go for the wowwipops.
Nmag
Posts: 1011
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Update

https://chaser.com.au/national/gamers-to-blame-for-indigestion-from-the-dinner-he-had-last-night-claims-nbn-chief/

The attack comes days after Bill Morrow attacked gamers for using the internet, claiming they were slowing down the network. He pleaded with users to stop using the NBN, pointing out it would be much faster if nobody used it.


PornoPete
Posts: 3210
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Gees that is some d******* language in a news report.

the attack comes days after the attackers attacked other victims of attack, while in attack formation using attack weapons.

*I'm testing something Jim*

I think I'll add something here.

If I were to use this argument I'd want to be pretty certain that the 58 killed and 2700 wounded were all a serious threat to elite soldiers, otherwise I'd be running the risk of supporting the literal slaughter of dozens and the indiscriminate wounding of thousands of people.


Hamas have now claimed 50 of the 60 people killed that day. Islamic jihad at least another 3. so let's do some "maths".

When performing the "indiscriminate wounding" of thousands the IDF managed to have a mathematically minimum possible ( 53/60*100= 88.3%) kill rate of confirmed terrorists while shooting into a crowd of 50K people.

For pointing out fpot is a complete f***ing ignoramus on this issue this I enjoy a one-hour post limit. My posts were purposely structured to demonstrate there is absolutely no difference between the so-called far right and garden-variety left-wing ideologues. In a sense, I suppose I did it too well. Hysterically fpot thinks he is an individual of moral fibre.

I point out further now, that the willingness to accuse the IDF of the most heinous of crimes (people literally make comparisons with Nuremberg on the basis of this mental diarrhoea *ie compare Jews to nazis*) *without any evidence of any kind* smacks of anti-Semitism. The kind now rampant in UK Labor and in the left wing generally.

I trust your moderation decision is proving comfortable with you mr moderator. You managed to side with the least informed most racist side of a debate. truly you've covered yourself in glory. I mean I wouldn't want to drown a forum with 3 posts a week in posts or anything.

I look forward to the epic takedown that is no doubt coming for comments like this:

I just saw your edit on the first dumb video. It's obvious you get very excited when a bitch gets told what's what. Completely normal behaviour you seem very well adjusted.


That's a totally reasonable take on what slaps posted. it's got a clear political leaning. that's probably a coincidence with no post limits and no nukes. the irony is if I posted tubgirl I'd be the bad guy.
Jim
Posts: 13760
Location:

Surely it gets a pass for obvious satire?
Nmag
Posts: 1012
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

The Chaser? All satire. https://chaser.com.au/
fpot
Posts: 26425
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Today the President of the United States, days after insulting and alienating the US's closest allies, met and shook hands with a brutal mass murderer and promised to be nicer to him in the future for... reasons. How do we know Kim isn't using the photos and event to go back to the DPRK and gather more adulation from his people by showing them and putting his own spin on it? trump gets played as a fool by a politically uninitiated porn star. Imagine what a true pro like Kim or Putin could do to him. No need to imagine - we're witnessing it.

Going back to the G7 Summit. Usually I can read certain twitter accounts and get some sort of semi-coherent narrative explaining trump's actions. They'll bring up something Obama or Clinton or whoever did years ago that bears some sort of superficial resemblance to it and say whatabout. Trump's childish conduct, his bizarre support of Russia that only makes sense if you assume something is true was unprecedented by any post cold war leader. Perhaps even before but my memory doesn't go back that far and I can't be bothered checking.
infi
Posts: 24075
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

The USA has tougher sanctions on both Russia and North Korea under Trump then under any President before. But Trump is still a bumbling Putin puppet.

Trump leaves the door open for these recalcitrants to return to the global arena if they can act like normal countries. In the meantime the crushing sanctions continue. Sounds solid to me.

I am also glad Trump gave a ton of stick to these G7 fakes who talk about liberalising trade all the while each country supports tarrifs and subsidies (as does the US). They almost s*** the bed when Trump off the cuff suggested that all G7 countries should just remove all their tarrifs.

This is the greatest show on earth, and seeing all these conventional establishment politicians appear bamboozled is exhilarating. I'm waiting for the world to blow up, it's gonna happen pretty shortly, I saw it is on MSNBC. Trump will implode soon. You just have to believe.

http://novonerd.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/Reaction-pic-Crying-meme.jpg
PornoPete
Posts: 3211
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Today fpot read Vox and it told him that Trump was bad.

Then he looked at some Twitter feeds of "the otherside" which support his childishly simple world view.

Then some school age activists tweeted a sick burn of drumph and fpot felt really right on.
Vash
Posts: 5788
Location:

Credit where credit is due, +1 to Trump for getting Kim to the negotiating table and securing an agreement. I doubt it would have happened with your run of the mill U.S President, but who knows.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 615
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Today fpot read Vox and it told him that Trump was bad.


fpot can read?
fpot
Posts: 26426
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Whoa dude with piercing wit like that you'll find yourself respected and admired by the alt-right conspiracy crowd in this thread in no time. To others you'll be nothing more than an unshaken piss droplet rolling down their pant leg. Still, that's probably an improvement over how your peers see you.

Credit where credit is due, +1 to Trump for getting Kim to the negotiating table and securing an agreement.
And that agreement is?

I really don't see how awful meeting and shaking hands with hyper awful can ever be a good thing.
PornoPete
Posts: 3212
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Whoa dude with piercing wit like that you'll find yourself respected and admired by the alt-right conspiracy crowd in this thread in no time.


fpot has shown his powers of reason. He deeply understands you see. Alt-right conspiracy crowd. Shame really if he had have thrown in nazi or racist I'd have had bingo.

And that agreement is?


Freely available for download, but guess who hasn't read it.
Vash
Posts: 5789
Location:


And that agreement is?

I really don't see how awful meeting and shaking hands with hyper awful can ever be a good thing.


It 's available on the net, but it might just work for reducing the tension on the Korean peninsula and increasing prosperity for North Korea. Putting aside how s***ty the Presidency & Kim's regime is. Sanders made an interesting comment that Trump is most comfortable with dealing with authoritarian leaders yet struggles with diplomacy of democratic nations heh
fpot
Posts: 26427
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

That's because he's desperate for respect amongst his peers but unable to get it because he's you know, s***. Instead he goes to the only place he can get it - dictators who will do or say anything to get a handshake with him so they can go back to their people and show them that they've now been anointed by the POTUS.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7867
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
c***s respect other c***s and Arseholes.

Whereas most c***s see other weak pricks as pussies.
Spook
Posts: 41106
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
one nation seems to be going well! (again)
PornoPete
Posts: 3213
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

That's because he's desperate for respect amongst his peers but unable to get it because he's you know, s***. Instead he goes to the only place he can get it - dictators who will do or say anything to get a handshake with him so they can go back to their people and show them that they've now been anointed by the POTUS.


Obama Cuba

Obama Iran

Obama Turkey

Obama Palestinian Authority

Obama Saudi Arabia

That's because he's desperate for respect amongst his peers but unable to get it because he's you know, s***.


That feeling when you think you have deep psychological insight but actually just project.
fpot
Posts: 26430
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I am pretty shocked that everything trump falsely accused the Hillary and co of were things that he was doing. Meanwhile children continue to be abducted at the border by ICE and then disappeared into the system. I guess it's not all bad though, it's not like trump is praising mass murderers for murdering people or anything.
PornoPete
Posts: 3214
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Fpot sure does get worked up at things he reads. Though strangely he has never read the primary sources.

He really cares about the children which is why he was so vocal before two weeks ago about ICE working according to the law which has been in place for about 10 years now.

Oh right.

Vox explained to him that Trump was really bad and so he's getting upset.

So how about those democrats hey. A 15 point lead is now a 3 point lead and the midterms are still months away.

Trump is on track to retain a supermajority. The TDS in November is going to be rich and creamy
infi
Posts: 24076
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Dems are a complete joke. I heard one Dem Congressman yesterday say that not all MS13 gang members are bad guys. lul

Imagine a pollie over here saying that not all outlaw bikie gang members are bad guys. But Dems have the race card to play.

American politics is f***ing awesome. Makes Aussie politics look like the Sheffield Shield.

And when Trump collects his Nobel peace Prize oh boy, what a time to be alive!
fpot
Posts: 26431
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

yeah yeah it's the dems who are a complete joke. When you first started having your lolbertarian tingles did you ever think you'd be defending a literal fascist who praises murderers and disappears children escaping from violence? You've certainly come a long way haven't you.
PornoPete
Posts: 3215
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

yeah yeah it's the dems who are a complete joke.


The polls don't lie.

You're defending a fascist infi. Fpot knows what this word means.

Other words fpot definitely understands include racist, chattel, disappear, abduct, peaceful protest and concentration camp.

There are others too. He's better than the OED.
Spook
Posts: 41109
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Imagine a pollie over here saying that not all outlaw bikie gang members are bad guys


https://www.qt.com.au/news/mp-to-join-biker-rally-on-moped/2092014/
Nmag
Posts: 1016
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Why are you so concerned about Trump fpot? Can you get past the main stream media?


waaaaaaaahhhhhh
Spook
Posts: 41110
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
ooooooh
infi
Posts: 24077
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

ooooooh


Spook, Ulysses bike club are a charity club. Lmao what a nitwit.
Viper119
Posts: 3392
Location: Other International

https://i.imgur.com/3cpAS6L.jpg
PornoPete
Posts: 3216
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

This is the kind secretary of defence the "I definately understand the word" fascist appoints.
Sanders made an interesting comment that Trump is most comfortable with dealing with authoritarian leaders yet struggles with diplomacy of democratic nations heh


oh, a lesson in being comfortable with authoritarian leaders from Bernie "Chavez gives us a new way of thinking about capitalism" Sanders. I wonder what Sanders said about mao in the in 60's.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7868
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Do you want know moar?

An analysis of Starship Troopers. Topics include war, dehumanization, propaganda, eugenics and more.


Insom
Posts: 4647
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

American politics is f***ing awesome.

it certainly inspires awe
taggs
Posts: 6557
Location:

Nmag can you stop? You're the fpot of the right.
fpot
Posts: 26435
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

You don't wanna be the fpot of the right mate. Then you'll do things like point out that the President of the United States, who isn't a fascist and was democratically elected, is still abducting children from their parents and placing them in concentration camps and will only stop if his border wall is funded. This is normal or maybe slightly erratic behaviour from a man who praises mass murderers for being tough and is not at all concerning. It actually kind of reminds me when people first started mentioning that trump may be a fascist and people would say things like... well at least he isn't putting people into camps. Perhaps certain members of this forum would like to update that with an at least he isn't doing x and we can see how long it is before he does that thing.
fpot
Posts: 26436
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

lol space force
dazedandconfused
Posts: 616
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

a) It is illegal for the US government to detain a child for longer than 20 days, therefore when their criminal parents accompany them and it takes longer than 20 days for processing, they must be removed into detention centres. Trump is telling Congress to write legislation addressing this as it's a result of precedent from a 1997 case. It has nothing to do with the Trump administration and everything to do with an incompetent Congress.

b) Obama also caged up kids lol so I sincerely hope you were frothing in 2014 about the exact issue. But you weren't, you just like to jump on the next leftie anti-Trump bandwagon issue and ride it into complete and utter nonsensical hilarity.
fpot
Posts: 26437
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

lol criminal parents, it's congress' fault and b..b..b..bbut Obama. Pretty much the complete pissbaby package aren't you?
PornoPete
Posts: 3217
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

You don't wanna be the fpot of the right mate. Then you'll do things like point out that the President of the United States, who isn't a fascist and was democratically elected, is still abducting children from their parents and placing them in concentration camps and will only stop if his border wall is funded. This is normal or maybe slightly erratic behaviour from a man who praises mass murderers for being tough and is not at all concerning. It actually kind of reminds me when people first started mentioning that trump may be a fascist and people would say things like... well at least he isn't putting people into camps. Perhaps certain members of this forum would like to update that with an at least he isn't doing x and we can see how long it is before he does that thing.


Literally noone thought the contents of that post were coming.

I refer to my list of words fpot definitely understands. He missed racist and disappear. But he was just trying to get the three points today mate, taking it one match at a time.

I rate it 7/10 sandy vages.

lol criminal parents, it's congress' fault and b..b..b..bbut Obama. Pretty much the complete pissbaby package aren't you?


Pissbaby that's a good one. Couldn't possibly be applied to the the above quoted passage.

But the thing is if all he's got is fpots rank hypocrisy, it's a pretty good thing to have.

Remember when fpot gave a detailed breakdown of the legal situation on border enforcement in the southern United States? Me neither. I do remember him complaining about Trump on this issue the second it hit the news outlets he likes, but never once before that.

That's political engagement.
infi
Posts: 24078
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Don't want to run into trouble with the immigration officials? Don't enter the country ILLEGALLY. get rid of them by all means necessary.

Just like our protector, Mr Dutton, does for Australia. God Bless him and his family.
fpot
Posts: 26438
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Don't want to run into trouble with the immigration officials? Don't enter the country ILLEGALLY. get rid of them by all means necessary.
Good little doggy. Your recital proves that you can at the very least memorise something and then repeat it. If only repetition worked for the truth as well as it does for lies.
PornoPete
Posts: 3218
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Good little doggy. Your recital proves that you can at the very least memorise something and then repeat it. If only repetition worked for the truth as well as it does for lies.


By comparison to the stunning examples of independent, deeply informed, clear thinking involved in his posts.

Fpot the deep thinker, doesn't simply repeat opinions from central opinions inc. he painstakingly types them out verbatim.

That's why he's better than you infi.
infi
Posts: 24079
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

It's not repetition fpot. it's actually this thing call THE LAW. But think of the children! The law applies to them too.
fpot
Posts: 26439
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Yes THE LAW. As opposed to the law which sometimes includes things that you whine about because it makes your life slightly less luxuriously set to impossible to fail mode. Big government you call it. All those needless regulations that surely aren't the product of years of precedence and trial and error but instead designed to persecute the truly aggrieved one here, you.

We then of course have THE LAW which has endless authority to f*** with whoever it wants at whatever cost. As long as that person is in an infi approved category such as homosexuals, asylum seekers, the poor, drug addicts, non-whites that is. Then the government can't possibly be big enough. Can't possibly spend enough money. As long as those people suffer infi is happy.
Spook
Posts: 41112
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
i wonder if we can get to 10000 posts of pointless bickering!
Nmag
Posts: 1018
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


ABC news today

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-06-19/nsw-budget-2018-winners-and-losers/9879148

The NSW Government said its 2018 budget is "for everyone" — but is it really? The ABC had broken down the numbers and cut through the spin to give you a list of who comes out on top and who misses out.


They give public sector the "loser" badge, and support their claim with:

The public sector wage cap is steady at 2.5 per cent, and it has not been reviewed since 2011. This is slightly above private sector growth, and above other states. The Treasurer did claim the state was a "wage leader", but with a huge $3.9 billion surplus, the introduction of the $3 billion NSW Generations Fund and the rising cost of living pressures, NSW Government workers may have a legitimate "Jerry Maguire" argument for the Treasurer: "Show me the money".


...

public sector wage cap is steady at 2.5 per cent
This is slightly above private sector growth, and above other states.


Have ABC assigned "loser" because public sector employees did not get as much as they feel entitled too?

It's "our ABC". The public funded mouth piece of unions, public servants, and left wing minorities masquerading as non-biased news.
paveway
Posts: 21541
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Haha holy f*** a 'space force'

He has accelerated towards destination crazy town
PornoPete
Posts: 3219
Location: Melbourne, Victoria


We then of course have THE LAW which has endless authority to f*** with whoever it wants at whatever cost. As long as that person is in an infi approved category such as homosexuals, asylum seekers, the poor, drug addicts, non-whites that is. Then the government can't possibly be big enough. Can't possibly spend enough money. As long as those people suffer infi is happy.


Infi is .... Wait for it

Wait for it....

Racist.

The actual legal situation doesn't need to be addressed when you can rely on calling people racist.

The retarded analogy fpot was trying to make is that because infi doesn't like some laws he is hypocritical for accepting the law as it is on the books is being enforced.

Except there is a yawing canyon between not liking a law and expecting it shouldn't be enforced.

If infi just didn't pay tax and complained that the ATO was being mean when they caught up with him it would be analogous.

Is there some good reason this
All those needless regulations that surely aren't the product of years of precedence and trial and error but instead designed to persecute the truly aggrieved one here, you.


Doesn't apply with exactly the same force to the laws fpot doesn't like?

It's not like immigration law was chucked together in 20 minutes.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7869
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
dazedandconfused
Posts: 617
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

If CNN reported instead how disgraceful it was that children were being detained by ICE for months with their parents as opposed to them being removed and placed in detention he'd whinge about that too. It's an unfortunate case of complete ignorance coupled with brain dead leftwing tribalism that produces bizzaro adults like fpot.
infi
Posts: 24080
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

All you gotta do is cry and the law need not apply.
Nmag
Posts: 1019
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

No need for logic when an issue can be sprinkled with self righteous illogical intent.
fpot
Posts: 26440
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

If CNN reported instead how disgraceful it was that children were being detained by ICE for months with their parents as opposed to them being removed and placed in detention he'd whinge about that too.
Damn right I would. See us non-fascists don't like to see people imprisoned who haven't committed crimes. I know that must be hard for you guys to understand but if you work really hard at it you might be able to figure it out.

See say I was you, a trump supporter trying to pretend I am something more than a reprehensible s*** pile that has somehow gained the ability to type. I'd be saying things like well tough immigration laws are good for border security, but surely a system can be devised where the parents can at least stay with their children, or know their whereabouts, or if they're dead or alive. I'd be saying things like why once these illegals have been deported why can't their children go with them, instead of being disappeared into the system?

Instead you're all in. You're literally advocating for internment camps for children where they're held hostage until trump can build his ridiculous wall which is a giant waste of f***ing money in its own right. To get to this stage you must live in an environment where nothing you do or say is ever criticised or scrutinised. I'm morbidly curious to know exactly what that environment is and just how badly you f***ed up to get there.

Oh and the US has left the UN Human Rights Council. Another triumph for the alt-right! Because who needs human rights when we have freedom of speech, giving us the right to proudly proclaim ourselves as nazis with zero repercussions.
PornoPete
Posts: 3220
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

See say I was you, a trump supporter trying to pretend I am something more than a reprehensible s*** pile that has somehow gained the ability to type. I'd be saying things like well tough immigration laws are good for border security, but surely a system can be devised where the parents can at least stay with their children, or know their whereabouts, or if they're dead or alive. I'd be saying things like why once these illegals have been deported why can't their children go with them, instead of being disappeared into the system?


Bingo!

Damn right I would. See us non-fascists don't like to see people imprisoned who haven't committed crimes. I know that must be hard for you guys to understand but if you work really hard at it you might be able to figure it out.


Literally only happening because they are being held awaiting trial. See this is what happens when you have reading difficulties.

You're literally advocating for internment camps for children where they're held hostage until trump can build his ridiculous wall which is a giant waste of f***ing money in its own right. To get to this stage you must live in an environment where nothing you do or say is ever criticised or scrutinised.


No he isn't?

Oh and the US has left the UN Human Rights Council. Another triumph for the alt-right! Because who needs human rights when we have freedom of speech, giving us the right to proudly proclaim ourselves as nazis with zero repercussions.


Chaired by saudi arabia, and has venezuela (who actually run political gulags) on it. but wait it gets better, who needs human rights when we have freedom of speech (a human right enshrined in the universal declaration of human rights and in the ICCPR).

we can add human rights to the things fpot doesn't understand.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 618
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

You're literally advocating for internment camps for children where they're held hostage


This is why you shouldn't ever bother explaining anything political with the left. Not only have I not even advocated for anything regarding immigration on this thread, fpot has also decided this non-advocation is akin to wanting internment camps swastika swastika Auschwitz gas chamber etc. And then he tops of the leftwing stereotype known for completely missing the point by repeatedly yelling alt-right. lolemoji lolemoji lolemoji
Raven
Posts: 9614
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
I'd actually like to know more about Trumps claim that this law has been in place for 60 years and they're only now working to get it changed. I know that Clinton actually introduced a whole heap of laws that made the situation worse, but they were never actually enforced.

The reality is both the extreme left and extreme right can be as bats*** crazy as each other.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39612
Location: Other International

I'd actually like to know more about Trumps claim that this law has been in place for 60 years and they're only now working to get it changed
Given almost everything else everyone in the administration has said about this issue has been a bald-faced lie, what do you reckon the chances are that was the one nugget of truth
infi
Posts: 24081
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Tucker Carlson the other night conveniently packaged together all the footage of democrats saying how bad illegal immigration is and how illegals should all be deported. Schumer, Hillary, Pelosi, Clinton, Obama. What a bunch of hypocrites.

I sent Peter Dutton a thank you card and a $2 scratchy this week. Our immigration system is the world's envy.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39613
Location: Other International

Tucker Carlson the other night conveniently packaged together all the footage of democrats saying how bad illegal immigration is and how illegals should all be deported. Schumer, Hillary, Pelosi, Clinton, Obama. What a bunch of hypocrites.
This is a strawman. It's not the topic being discussed anywhere.
infi
Posts: 24082
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

This is a strawman. It's not the topic being discussed anywhere.


They are discussing their support of the legislation which you state you are not sure exists.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39614
Location: Other International

noone doubts there is legislation about immigration. that's why it's a strawman.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39615
Location: Other International

watching the mental gymnastics of people trying desperately to avoid having to say 'separating children from their parents is bad' until Dear Leader does has been entertaining though, in a grim kind of way
PornoPete
Posts: 3221
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

This is a strawman. It's not the topic being discussed anywhere.


Ahem.

It's not a strawman. It is the topic being discussed. To deport illegal immigrants you need to arrest them.

If they have children, the law requires that US authorities separate the children while the parents are detained awaiting trial/deportation.

It is not possible to enforce the law and deport illegal immigrants in the US without separating children from parents. That's why DACA existed. That's why catch and release existed.

It follows, that if you believe illegals should be deported you are necessarily accepting child separation unless you change the law. The two issues are inextricably linked.

Not a single one of those named democrats did change the law, despite the fact the law has been in the books in its current form for the entire Obama administration. They could've. They didn't.

Therefore hypocrisy.

watching the mental gymnastics of people trying desperately to avoid having to say 'separating children from their parents is bad' until Dear Leader does has been entertaining though, in a grim kind of way


Not as fun as watching people work themselves into a thick creamy lather over an issue that has remained unchanged for over a decade, because we must #resist.
infi
Posts: 24083
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

I am fine with the most extreme response. i disagree with trump stopping the separations. the parents are selfish and irresponsible for putting their children at risk.
Nmag
Posts: 1020
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Export the lot. Keep them together.
fpot
Posts: 26441
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I am fine with the most extreme response. i disagree with trump stopping the separations. the parents are selfish and irresponsible for putting their children at risk.
If you were living during the times of Nazi Germany you would be one of the people mass murdering people. I really want to stress the lack of hyperbole or exaggeration in what I just said. You are a sick demented f*** and there is no limit to what your need to see people suffering would make you do. You'd be throwing the Zyklon B down the grate and laughing with your brethren as the pyramid of bodies piles up against the door. I wish really profound suffering upon you.
PornoPete
Posts: 3222
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

If you were living during the times of Nazi Germany you would be one of the people mass murdering people. I really want to stress the lack of hyperbole or exaggeration in what I just said.


fpot found a nazi.

again.

so with all this watching of mental gymnastics, trog darling, do you think he stuck the landing? Or is this sandy vagina rabid frothing?

fpot really has tried to be reasonable. he has carefully explained the legal and economic drivers on the situation. and infi has obtusely refused to listen to a carefully set out and well-referenced argument.

Well not quite. fpot got angry when he was dog-whistled, and like a good little doggy, he is dutifully expressing the authorised opinion.

Fpot has never shown any indication he has even the slightest understanding of an issue. He just jumps to 'you're a nazi'. He thinks hate speech is super important and then spouts something like this:
You'd be throwing the Zyklon B down the grate and laughing with your brethren as the pyramid of bodies piles up against the door. I wish really profound suffering upon you.


But its never hate speech when you're fpot.

fpot is a profoundly stupid and shallow individual.
Vash
Posts: 5790
Location:

Yeah going by Infi's lack of empathy you have to wonder.

Those parents are so selfish for putting their children at risk by attempting to give them a better life & escape the reign of murderous cartels.
PornoPete
Posts: 3223
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Yeah going by Infi's lack of empathy you have to wonder.


Woops there's no show with out retard punch.

You have to wonder if infi would joyfully mass murder people?

Vash and fpot have a deep insight into people's psychology. They also like to wank each other off to really gone there insights about people.

The best part about it is you f***ing morons think you're resisting instead of being dog whistled.
PornoPete
Posts: 3224
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

ACLU finds systematic abuse of children in detention between 2009 and 2014.

I look forward to people who don't do mental gymnastics explaining how they never said s*** for the better part of a decade, but now they care.

The hard truth is it was Obama and so you didn't care.

You aren't brave or morally right now if you didn't speak then. You're an idiotic hypocrite.

Here is a taste of Obama immigration policy


Punched a child’s head three times
Kicked a child in the ribs
Used a stun gun on a boy, causing him to fall to the ground, shaking, with his eyes rolling back in his head
Ran over a 17-year-old with a patrol vehicle and then punched him several times
Verbally abused detained children, calling them dogs and “other ugly things”
Denied detained children permission to stand or move freely for days and threatened children who stood up with transfer to solitary confinement in a small, freezing room
Denied a pregnant minor medical attention when she reported pain, which preceded a stillbirth
Subjected a 16-year-old girl to a search in which they “forcefully spread her legs and touched her private parts so hard that she screamed”
Left a 4-pound premature baby and her minor mother in an overcrowded and dirty cell full of sick people, against medical advice
Threw out a child’s birth certificate and threatened him with sexual abuse by an adult male detainee.


Yous didn't say s***.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 619
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

If you were living during the times of Nazi Germany you would be one of the people mass murdering people. I really want to stress the lack of hyperbole or exaggeration in what I just said. You are a sick demented f*** and there is no limit to what your need to see people suffering would make you do. You'd be throwing the Zyklon B down the grate and laughing with your brethren as the pyramid of bodies piles up against the door. I wish really profound suffering upon you.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Deg7VrpHbM
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39616
Location: Other International

wtf @ melananaiaiana ? these people are just trash
PornoPete
Posts: 3225
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

wtf @ melananaiaiana ? these people are just trash


Ooooh it's like a Pavlovian Pomeranian. Yap yap yap.
fpot
Posts: 26442
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

wtf @ melananaiaiana ? these people are just trash
Extraordinary isn't it? I am holding out hope that she isn't a terrible person and she's doing it just so she can avoid another black eye.
PornoPete
Posts: 3226
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I am holding out hope that she isn't a terrible person and she's doing it just so she can avoid another black eye.


And alternatively wanking to the idea.
Jim
Posts: 13761
Location:

I am fine with the most extreme response. i disagree with trump stopping the separations. the parents are selfish and irresponsible for putting their children at risk.


ok, but what are the transgressions of their children?
Also, is that why the law exists - as a punitive measure for selfish/irresponsible parents?
Jim
Posts: 13762
Location:

If you were living during the times of Nazi Germany you would be one of the people mass murdering people. I really want to stress the lack of hyperbole or exaggeration in what I just said.


I had to re-read the second sentence because the first really looks like hyperbole. Can you show how it isn't? To me there seems a pretty big leap between someone who makes comments from time to time that seem a bit lacking in empathy, and someone who actively participated in the murder of large numbers of people
fpot
Posts: 26443
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Because infi over many years and many posts has demonstrated that he is all these things -

- incredibly gullible
- derives satisfaction from the suffering of people in the categories I mentioned a few posts ago
- believes without question the words of the people who are conducting this cruelty - Dutton here and trump over there
- is a white supremacist
- is a liar

Stick him in an environment where oversight is taken away and he is given carte blanche by his superiors to do whatever he wants and he will. All you'd need to do is to tell him that it's for the preservation of the country, or western culture or any weak ass nationalistic bulls***. "Savage treatment is all savages understand" were his words when describing the detainees at Gitmo. He lied about that for months and he'll lie about it again.

The actions of Nazi Germany were extraordinary and will probably never be repeated again or at least I hope not. What was ordinary were the circumstances leading up to it and the people who conducted it. At first anyway.

These people are animals infesting our country are genocidal words and infi believes it all. Once someone is able to fool themselves into thinking this way is good and proper it endlessly expands their own horizons on their capability for inflicting horror.
PornoPete
Posts: 3227
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

ok, but what are the transgressions of their children?
Also, is that why the law exists - as a punitive measure for selfish/irresponsible parents?


The law exists for the welfare of the child. This is the express reasoning in the flores decision.

The reasoning goes that children can't be detained in a "jail" regardless of what the parents have done.

Flores requires that you either let the whole family go, which has been resulting in making it virtually impossible to enforce the law, which I might add probably puts it on shakey constitutional ground, or you separate the family and prosecute parents.

The constitutional issue is raised because flores relies on executive discretion in law enforcement, but that discretion is not unlimited, any use of discretion which amounts to a systematic refusal to enforce the laws Congress has written will be overruled in court. That's what happened to DAPA.

Flores exists literally because family detention was being used as a deterrent method.

Any analysis that does not deal with the perverse incentive that creates to bring children with you to cross the border is willfully ignorant.

Heh fpot unlocks level 99 retardation.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7870
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
fpot = Nazi Hunter (level eleventy bajillion)
PornoPete
Posts: 3228
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Yes, and he, like all nazi hunters, combines it with a profound ignorance of how the nazi's came to power.

nazis separated children at Auschwitz is just as intelligent as pointing out nazis built roads.

Meanwhile, in a lesson that definitely won't be learned. Time Magazine issue a pretty f***ing major correction about their most recent cover. the crying girl was at no time separated from her mother. Her mother who was not fleeing violence and just trying to find better employment and was deported from the US in 2013 (meaning this crossing was a felony) *and* took the child without telling the father or the rest of the family, meaning she plausibly kidnapped the child and paid people smugglers to get her to the border.

In short, the exact f***ing reason you can't let children straight across the border. It creates the situation you are trying to avoid.

but instead of dealing with the perverse incentive, it's much easier to flick that bean to the outrage machine. We can all pat ourselves on the back that we are super emotionally connected when we say separating children from parents is bad mkay. Everyone who disagrees with me would definitely kill jews.

just to add a bit more fuel.

Update: Time is standing by its cover. Editor-in-chief Edward Felsenthal says in a statement: “The June 12 photograph of the 2-year-old Honduran girl became the most visible symbol of the ongoing immigration debate in America for a reason: Under the policy enforced by the administration, prior to its reversal this week, those who crossed the border illegally were criminally prosecuted, which in turn resulted in the separation of children and parents. Our cover and our reporting capture the stakes of this moment.


It's ok to exploit a child crying if it serves the narrative; it was true in spirit (the fire and fury defence, our baseless crude caricature *feels* right). Mr Felsenthal should be ashamed and should lose his job. But he won't. Now anyone who'd like to discuss Russian bots, might want to put a really f***ing good reason forward why this isn't the actual problem. pretty easy I think to draw a straight line from that to dog whistle joe above feeling like people who disagree with him are mass murders in waiting.
infi
Posts: 24084
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

that time magazine cover is an epic troll. they are now up there with buzzfeed and cnbc. i never thought time magazine aspired to compete for fake news status. lulzy

a doctored photo depicts the current situatiuon? hah! imagine a respected journalist institution being turned into a joke instantly in an effort to stay woke. TDS strikes again.

fake news, girl never separated from mother, actually kidnapped from father by mother

ok, but what are the transgressions of their children?
Also, is that why the law exists - as a punitive measure for selfish/irresponsible parents?


great question! the security of a country's border is paramount over everything else. once coyotes (people smugglers) dictate who gets to enter the country then a sovereign nation has lost control. 8/10 women smuggled across the border are raped. this is unacceptable and must be deterred with the harshest penalties.

just as peter dutton has established, the strong deterrent detention stops the pull factor. the US illegal child entrants reside in very similar surrounds as Australian child immigration detainees. clean, safe and fed. it was good enough for Obama but now it's a problem because?

If the parents are going to jail then the children will need to be placed in care with a family member back in their home country so they will remain separated. What happens when a mother enters prison pregnant?

It's most likely Trump flipped on the child separation due to one very influential person.... Can you guess?

wow fpot i go away from the forum for 2 days and you lose your mind. this is like the shining.
PornoPete
Posts: 3229
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

a doctored photo depicts the current situatiuon?

It kind of does represent Time's current situation.
fpot
Posts: 26445
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Thanks for demonstrating in one clean post that all of these things

incredibly gullible
- derives satisfaction from the suffering of people in the categories I mentioned a few posts ago
- believes without question the words of the people who are conducting this cruelty - Dutton here and trump over there
- is a white supremacist
- is a liar


are true.
PornoPete
Posts: 3230
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

If you just stick your fingers in your ears, stamp your feet and scream racist it has to be true.

I reckon fpot is really really concerned about the children. wants to take part in children's "protests". he's really passionate about children. he really likes those 80's Michael Jackson music videos with children in them.

nazi Germany.

white supremacist.

the holocaust.

I know how to politics.
Nmag
Posts: 1021
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

When emotion overrides the brain.
PornoPete
Posts: 3231
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

well quite.
for example this comment:
believes without question the words of the people who are conducting this cruelty - Dutton here and trump over there

fails to recognise the radically different situations and the fact that Dutton and Trump are being lambasted for pursuing diametrically opposed policies.

Dutton is locking children up, Trump is not.

But that doesn't matter, nothing is complex, there are no hard choices in immigration. there are just racists who disagree with you. sorry nazis in waiting who'd definitely kill people if no one was watching.
fpot
Posts: 26448
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

mmm directly into my veins please. Goes very well with that Homeland Security person being heckled in the restaurant. The more this sort of thing happens the better. The only way these cretinous f***s will learn is if they start to become personally affected by their actions.
PornoPete
Posts: 3232
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

The more this sort of thing happens the better. The only way these cretinous f***s will learn is if they start to become personally affected by their actions.


See fpot is so smart that he thinks this kind of petty publicity is amazing. Like a BuzzFeed article where the restaurant owner has a perfect response to Trump.

He's so smart he hasn't noticed that this whole affair hasn't hurt Trumps polling or the Republican party's polling.

People want something done about the illegal immigration at the border and they understand just refusing to enforce the law because a child happens to be present causes the child to be there.

But he understands the word "cretinous". That's why he lives for the next ten reasons Huckabee Sanders is a hose beast article. I'm sure shell be able to find comfort eating the private chefs menu at the Whitehouse untill 2024. Because it's exactly this kind of idiotic s*** that gets fpot so wet that'll make it happen.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39620
Location: Other International

mmm directly into my veins please. Goes very well with that Homeland Security person being heckled in the restaurant. The more this sort of thing happens the better. The only way these cretinous f***s will learn is if they start to become personally affected by their actions.
I disagree. I think it will turn into [even more of] a race to the bottom, as evidenced by the totally predictable behaviour of Sanders as a result. The business is now in the cross-hairs of rabid ideologues, possibly dangerous people. At the risk of slippery sloping, I can't imagine anything more destructive to whatever slim hopes the US have of returning to a rational society than splitting their eating and drinking establishments along party lines so their increasingly aristocratic politicians feel like they have a safe space to eat.
PornoPete
Posts: 3233
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I disagree. I think it will turn into [even more of] a race to the bottom, as evidenced by the totally predictable behaviour of Sanders as a result. The business is now in the cross-hairs of rabid ideologues, possibly dangerous people. At the risk of slippery sloping, I can't imagine anything more destructive to whatever slim hopes the US have of returning to a rational society than splitting their eating and drinking establishments along party lines so their increasingly aristocratic politicians feel like they have a safe space to eat.


Classic Nazi talk. anyone who thinks that a bunch of narcissist utterly ineffective protestors harassing the secretary of the DHS at every opportunity isn't like totally justified is obviously a Nazi sympathizer.
fpot
Posts: 26450
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

heh yeah you're probably right. Just seeing this scum face consequences, any consequences, for their actions excites a certain part of my brain. Just need to be a little patient I guess and wait a couple more years.
infi
Posts: 24086
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

So if you are associated with the country's leader you get banned from attending businesses without retaliation from the leader? Definitely sounds like Nazi Germany, a very slippery slope. The business owners are pussy hat wearing imbeciles. They will no doubt thrive in DC.
fpot
Posts: 26453
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

wah wah
dazedandconfused
Posts: 620
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

You might have 1% of 1% of a point in an alternate universe fpot but you're unfortunately selectively outraged so your credibility is shot.
Nmag
Posts: 1022
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Why doesn't US take over Mexico?

Just need all the way down to this narrow bit:

https://www.google.com.au/maps/@17.1562405,-94.7818425,9z

Sell off the remaining eastern bit to the highest suitable bidder.

Then build a massive wall, and put a few hundred navy ships to patrol.

or, go all the way to Panama City:

https://www.google.com.au/maps/@8.6292033,-78.8198878,8z

It's not like they don't have the war-appetite to do something like that.

The nazi references are so ridiculous it's hard not to laugh. How far can TDS go?

Identify a common enemy, foster hatred, bond group. Do you have a figurehead to apply hatred fpot? Hanson, Trump Dutton. I count three people you likely 'hate'.

The is no individual like that, that I hate. I dislike supporting lazy people. I don't actually hate any particular Greens leader.

I believe your hatred is misplaced, and that hatred does not help. Emotion fogs the mind. Seek Jesus, and/or professional help. Maybe a magic crystal has the power to help you?

Anger won't help.


PornoPete
Posts: 3234
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

So if you are associated with the country's leader you get banned from attending businesses without retaliation from the leader? Definitely sounds like Nazi Germany, a very slippery slope. The business owners are pussy hat wearing imbeciles. They will no doubt thrive in DC.
wah wah


I wonder what fpots opinion of the masterpiece cakes decision was?

He's a bit slow, so he probably doesn't know how far down the slippery slope he is.
Vash
Posts: 5791
Location:

Why doesn't US take over Mexico? Just need all the way down to this narrow bit:
Seek Jesus, and/or professional help


You might need to take your own advice there lil fella.
fpot
Posts: 26454
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

Not long now till his alt account will be activated in this thread.
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7871
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
The nazi references are so ridiculous it's hard not to laugh.


https://s22.postimg.cc/p4vlsta2p/kampf.jpg
fpot
Posts: 26455
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

I'd struggle to argue with that too.
PornoPete
Posts: 3235
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I struggle to argue.


Fixed
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39621
Location: Other International

So if you are associated with the country's leader you get banned from attending businesses without retaliation from the leader?


Serious question time though:

1) how many Republicans and/or libertarians are standing up saying "I support this small business owner's right to refuse service to whoever they want and wish every business could do this in all circumstances", out of interest? (not counting Rand or Ron Paul)

2) I don't quite understand why it's OK for the restaurant to refuse service in this scenario actually. What's the difference between refusing to bake a cake for someone because they're gay, and refusing to serve them dinner because you saw them on TV and don't like their job performance? I think restaurants need to have some rights to refuse service (e.g., drunk, disorderly, no shoes, whatever), but not sure about just because someone is a serial liar, even if them being a liar is a) the whole reason for their employment as a lying mouthpiece for a bunch of dishonest liars and b) it's destabilising the entire planet
fpot
Posts: 26456
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

The difference is that it's perfectly okay to be gay but it's not perfectly okay to be a major cog in the serial human rights violations that are currently occurring on the southern border.
PornoPete
Posts: 3236
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

The difference is that it's perfectly okay to be gay but it's not perfectly okay to be a major cog in the serial human rights violations that are currently occurring on the southern border.


Life is easy when you're retarded.

Its not perfectly ok to force people endorse your relationship.
PornoPete
Posts: 3237
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

burned animal corpse left on DHS staff door step.

Fpot gets his jollies.

I wonder if phooks will be in here soon to detail the very strong link between cruelty to animals and psychopathy. Probably not the resistance ends are justified because the end of the world is here with Nazis.

I reckon the Russians put them up to it, and there isn't a mass hysteria breaking out which is completely immune to fact or reason.

The Russian also made Maxine Waters go out a publicly demand this kind of behaviour.
Raven
Posts: 9615
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
2) I don't quite understand why it's OK for the restaurant to refuse service in this scenario actually. What's the difference between refusing to bake a cake for someone because they're gay, and refusing to serve them dinner because you saw them on TV and don't like their job performance? I think restaurants need to have some rights to refuse service (e.g., drunk, disorderly, no shoes, whatever), but not sure about just because someone is a serial liar, even if them being a liar is a) the whole reason for their employment as a lying mouthpiece for a bunch of dishonest liars and b) it's destabilising the entire planet


Somewhere along the long timeline, the rights of businesses flipped from "WE as society are permitting YOU as a business to operate in our community, on the condition that you serve the needs of the community" to "You as a community owe us as a business for providing to you". It's rather bizarre.

I do kinda understand the free-market stance in the sentiment that a business should be free to do whatever the hell they want within the bounds of the law, and let the customers decide if they want to support that behaviour - I just don't believe it results in a positive outcome to society on the whole because people will sacrifice ideals for convenience, availability and affordability.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 621
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

and b) it's destabilising the entire planet
https://memegenerator.net/img/images/11023375/patrick-stewart-head-in-hands.jpg
Somewhere along the long timeline, the rights of businesses flipped from "WE as society are permitting YOU as a business to operate in our community, on the condition that you serve the needs of the community" to "You as a community owe us as a business for providing to you". It's rather bizarre.


It's rather bizarre when the socialist indoctrination has been so utterly successful that people now think that private property (ie someone's business) is somehow community property.

https://crossfitfms.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/photo.jpg
fpot
Posts: 26458
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

https://i.imgur.com/kZzOvF0.pnghttps://i.imgur.com/r99tLoS.pnghttps://i.imgur.com/u5a7rGX.png

Abducted children being threatened if they talk to reporters.

Not fascist. Just slightly erratic.
Raven
Posts: 9616
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
It's rather bizarre when the socialist indoctrination has been so utterly successful that people now think that private property (ie someone's business) is somehow community property.


That's not even remotely socialist, nor what was said or even implied - but I'll make sure to feel sorry for the poor straw man you just gathered, built, doused, and set on fire.

We allow corporations to operate in society under rules and restrictions that they must follow, which are there in order to protect society as a whole. This idea that they're doing some kind of service for people and therefore people owe them something is so utterly bulls*** it's not funny. They're operating a business for the purpose of making a profit. The moment they can't take money from the public, they'll stop doing it, it's that simple.
infi
Posts: 24087
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

"WE as society are permitting YOU as a business to operate in our community, on the condition that you serve the needs of the community" to "You as a community owe us as a business for providing to you".


wrong. private citizens are generally free to associate (or not associate) with whomever they please (organised criminals and union thugs excluded). there is, nor never was, a community obligation for any private business, club or association to deal with anyone. it is illegal to discriminate, but it is not illegal to dislike someone. this is the essence of liberty. there are permits required for every business, and once satisfied, the owner's demeanour is on them. both the restaurant and the baker should be free to serve who they please, but be prepared for the resultant blowback.

that may involve the president detaining you and your family, and gassing and incinerating them.
fpot
Posts: 26459
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

No need for that. So much evidence left behind. Better to seperate the families and then create a wall of bureaucracy so thick that the parents will never be able to penetrate it. Sure, you can see your child again, all you need to do is sign this confession and then be refouled. All perfectly legal in non-fascist USA.
PornoPete
Posts: 3238
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Except refoulement is only something that can be done to refugees.

Less than 1% of people illegally crossing the southern border are given refugee status.

See this is what happens when you've learnt a few bits of jargon and think you know a subject area.
Nmag
Posts: 1024
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Donald Trump is a big, angry baby


Its funny because it's not Trump who's crying like a baby. It's those who feel for the feels of those feeling the feels who are doing the crying. From memory, he won the election, and Clinton supporters were doing the crying. He's a winner, and some have dedicated themselves to crying about it for 4 years. These sooks don't even live in the US, they are crying tears of empathy, enraged by the twisted news they subscribe too.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/image/9914504-3x2-700x467.jpghttp://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-06-27/trump-baby:-uk-activists-work-to-get-blimp-flying-during-visit/9914002

It is all pretty funny. I expect this will all be more interesting in 10 years.
Vash
Posts: 5792
Location:

https://streamable.com/zy1p7

Fox News vs. North Korean State TV

heheh
Spook
Posts: 41116
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
come on bros

lets limp this bitch to 10000!
PornoPete
Posts: 3239
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

The meltdown over Trump getting two supreme court picks has been very tasty. When you consider Ruth Bader Ginsburg is 85 he could potentially get three.

Entertaining to watch all the people who loved Kennedy for writing the majority opinion in hedges say he is a right-wing kook now. Dude literally legalised gay marriage in the US and lefties are calling him a right-wing conservative.

81 year old man retires when someone I don't like will appoint his replacement, therefore, I hate his guts.

Just for you spook
Insom
Posts: 4649
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Ginsburg must live, I don't care if they need to preserve her head in a jar like on Futurama
Nmag
Posts: 1025
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Today on "Your ABC", the unbiased news source:

http://www.abc.net.au/news/image/9921418-3x4-700x933.jpghttp://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-06-28/bom-staff-hijack-website-forecasts-in-pay-dispute/9921398

Using public service funds (ABC) to give air to a separate public service dispute (BOM).

"But it's still not as good as what other agencies have been able to achieve. "It's frustrating, because management could shift more."


Which are both likely to be more than the average private sector increase. They are holding out, that is why they are 'suffering'. I suggest they go to private sector if the conditions are not ideal, and see how that goes. Better not privatise the BOM, it will introduce capitalist corruption, they might forecast weather that their shareholders want.


sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7872
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
...interesting

Nmag
Posts: 1027
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

You cannot post yet! Due to post limiting, you can only post 1 message every 18000 seconds.


Vash is one of my alts
Vash
Posts: 5794
Location:

^thats what happens when you're not subtle enough with your trolling.
Nmag
Posts: 1028
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


President Baron Waqa has been a critic of the ABC.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-07-02/baron-waqa/9932430

http://www.abc.net.au/news/image/4751246-3x4-700x933.jpg
PornoPete
Posts: 3240
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Jonathon Pie crushing it.

Nmag
Posts: 1029
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Where news comes from.

Today's front page of Guardian news has a small extract of a large cartoon under the heading "Spotlight"

https://www.theguardian.com/au

Links to:

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jul/03/fiona-the-underemployed-bettong-v-malcolm-goldplated-trufflecustard-turnbull

Which includes the image by "Cartoon by First Dog on the Moon"

which states at the bottom

certain facts from unemployed workers union
http://unemployedworkersunion.com/

Know your rights as an unemployed person claiming welfare, and follow Guardian news.

http://unemployedworkersunion.com/your-rights/

When will ABC link to this article by The Guardian? I'm sure the're tempted.

You don't need to look for work or participate in work for the dole if you get the right medical certificate. The unemployed workers union can provide advice if your medical certificate is rejected.

The AUWU has received many shocking cases of seriously ill people having their medical certificates rejected by Centrelink, The AUWU made contact with Australian Medical Association (AMA) in regards to this issue with the hope of working together to bring Centrelink into line. The AMA made some inquiries to Centrelink about how the system of obtaining medical exemptions works. The AUWU was informed that if your medical certificate is rejected you are entitled to a full explanation both over the phone and in writing as to why an exemption has not been provided. You also have a right to review.

PornoPete
Posts: 3241
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

dazedandconfused
Posts: 622
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I am absolutely loving the Leyonjhelm vs Sea Patrol Sarah saga. The disingenuousness coming from the left to contort her into being right is absolute gold.
Insom
Posts: 4650
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

we’ve found what that blowhard Leyonhjelm is good for - provoking the so called left and then luxuriating in their outrage

seems familiar
PornoPete
Posts: 3242
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

You'd think the "so-called" left would learn. Four years in and progress on that front is glacial.

Hason-young needs the boy who called wolf tattooed to her forehead.

male feminist gropes woman. doesnt "listen and believe".
Spook
Posts: 41118
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
getting closer.

ive got balloons and poppers ready to go!@
fpot
Posts: 26462
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland

mmmm yeah that BITCH is gettin' told. So good. Almost makes up for all that female rejection in my life. Soon you won't need the extra tissue for tears and you'll be able to masturbate with only one if this sort of thing keeps up, dazed.

we’ve found what that blowhard Leyonhjelm is good for - provoking the so called left and then luxuriating in their outrage
This is literally what all the figurehead right-wing politicians do. Say and do horrible things which normal people react badly to and then say look at the waves I'm creating, I am awesome! When they don't do this (Turnbull for instance) they tend to be loathed.
Nmag
Posts: 1030
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I read a post from a friend today "Embarrassed to be Australian, again" with an image of some Aussie basketball player elbowing a Filipino in the neck in basketball. Typical of this guy. A screenshot taken out of context. Overall the Filipino's acted like wild animals, but he favours the screen-grab his news feed uses.
PornoPete
Posts: 3243
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

mmmm yeah that BITCH is gettin' told. So good. Almost makes up for all that female rejection in my life. Soon you won't need the extra tissue for tears and you'll be able to masturbate with only one if this sort of thing keeps up, dazed.


Geez that language sure does come easy to fpot doesn't it. He doesn't want to have to type it out but for some reason he can't quite put his finger on he is compelled to. Like a cry for help.

This is literally what all the figurehead right-wing politicians do. Say and do horrible things which normal people react badly to and then say look at the waves I'm creating, I am awesome! When they don't do this (Turnbull for instance) they tend to be loathed.


Fpot uses brain. Gets headache
Vash
Posts: 5795
Location:

we’ve found what that blowhard Leyonhjelm is good for - provoking the so called left and then luxuriating in their outrage seems familiar


Heh indeed. It's like these people for years couldn't handle being proven wrong on important issues now just take delight in outraging their political opponents. You know you've failed at life when you just go full troll, which is basically what the right has become.

This needs to be posted again when it comes to Leyonhjelm.

https://i.imgur.com/1HYkUxa.jpg
Spook
Posts: 41119
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG
i wonder if the forum is going to IMPLODE!?@
Spook
Posts: 41120
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
YASSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
Spook
Posts: 41121
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
where were you when this happened!?

https://i.imgur.com/OM5l3jj.jpg
infi
Posts: 24088
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

making history through retardation.
Insom
Posts: 4651
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

10k posts and we still haven't made any progress
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39625
Location: Other International

Leyonhjelm: we need truly free speech so that everyone can compete equally in the marketplace of ideas

Also Leyonhjelm: bitches be trippin'
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39626
Location: Other International

Might lock this thread so we can kick off a new one; I think the size of it has been causing some grief server-side. Anyone want to get in some last bon mots?
infi
Posts: 24089
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Great idea.
Hogfather
Posts: 16854
Location: Cairns, Queensland

Adieu, s***stain of the Internet.

May the next s***filled political thread be just as awful.
Raven
Posts: 9617
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
Adieu, s***stain of the Internet.

May the next s***filled political thread be just as awful.


I propose the next one be split in to two threads:

Political Thread 3A: For left-leaning posters only.
Political Thread 3B: For right-leaning posters only.

Then the two of you can argue over who should have been A and who should have been B.
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 39627
Location: Other International

there are more than two choices
Insom
Posts: 4652
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

thread 3C, far-centre and swinging voters
PornoPete
Posts: 3244
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Leyonhjelm: we need truly free speech so that everyone can compete equally in the marketplace of ideas

Also Leyonhjelm: bitches be trippin'


Hanson-young:. We need to limit free speech because it allows people to perpetuate harmful stereotypes which oppress people

Also Hanson-young: all men are rapists.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 623
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

Did Leyonhjelm complain about names shouted at him? Pretty sure he didn't care and that Hanson-Young with her 4th grade intellect made it into national news. Pretty sure he, like everyone on the right is when invited to the absolute circus that is left wing outrage hysteria, is simply basking in the comedic value. Fpot trying his little heart out to get personal is also complete evidence that you're getting under his skin and is equally valuable humour.
Raven
Posts: 9618
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
there are more than two choices

Let's be honest, those of us who sit somewhere in the middle tend to not bother getting in to these discussions because it's bad enough just getting called names by one side when they don't like what you're saying, having both sides resort to name-calling just makes you find it not worth wasting your time on them.
Vash
Posts: 5796
Location:

Literally every post here by a right leaning moron is 'lol basking in the comedic value of the leftist hysteria' Zero thought or analysis into the situation. Really shines the spot light on the pieces of s*** of society.

Leyonhjelm made his comments based on Hanson-Young saying 'All men are rapists' which isn't what she said. He is in the wrong, and not just leftists are saying that.
PornoPete
Posts: 3245
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Literally every post here by a right leaning moron is 'lol basking in the comedic value of the leftist hysteria' Zero thought or analysis into the situation. Really shines the spot light on the pieces of s*** of society.


Contradiction within a single sentence. Vintage vash.

Leyonhjelm made his comments based on Hanson-Young saying 'All men are rapists' which isn't what she said. He is in the wrong, and not just leftists are saying that.


She just thinks that we live in a society which organised solely to benefit men, rape is pervasive and endorsed by society, and we train men to rape.

But the outrage follows a sustained period of low profile and reduced portfolio responsibility. Sounds like someone might need to show relevance
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 7873
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Virginia owns this f***wit

infi
Posts: 24090
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Can't wait for the prison hunger strike.
Nmag
Posts: 1031
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

According to Vash, even a person who is 'right leaning' is a moron. To quote the wise man himself:

leftist hysteria
leftist hysteria
leftist hysteria
leftist hysteria
leftist hysteria
PornoPete
Posts: 3246
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Can't wait for the prison hunger strike.


Personally I'm not going to eat until I next get hungry in solidarity.

I personally can't believe such sexist rape apologist language which trains men to be rapists was allowed on the ABC. I thought the ABC wasn't a fascist organisation, but Virginia used the word bitchy.

Gendered language like that in 2018.

There needs to be a reflection pool so people can properly process the horror if tonight's events.

I mean from bitchy it's fiesty and then from there it's pack rape.
trillion
Posts: 4404
Location: Ballarat, Victoria
tbh Tri when she's not chilling on the morning news with old mate chatting about something nice, is kind of snarky

last edited by trillion at 22:38:27 05/Jul/18
Nmag
Posts: 1032
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

She's a hawt lefty
PornoPete
Posts: 3247
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

I actually hold Virginia in high esteem. But the wig out over language in the senate is a farce and everyone knows it.

The greens need column inches and nothing more. The point is even while taking someone to task over their heinous gendered language a professional reporter managed to make a hypocrite of herself inside 5 minutes.

If hanson-young wants respect she should try not confusing tv drama with reality.
dazedandconfused
Posts: 624
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

She has a Bachelor in Social Science. That about sums up the entirety of her, to be honest.
Nmag
Posts: 1033
Location: Sydney, New South Wales


Next to Michael Rowland being so professional, she does come across as unprofessional and fairly biased at times. But she has bigger boobs and better nips than Michael, and that's what really matters.

https://forums.auscelebs.net/viewtopic.php?f=88&amp;t=14168


infi
Posts: 24092
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

Virginia Trioli is not a journalist. She's an activist employed by the ABC.

Now I am going back into my cry closest to centre myself while I think about the numerous microagressions I may have inflicted today on every identity type in Australia (excepting for whites males of course because they cannot be discriminated against due to their privilege).
Raven
Posts: 9619
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
She has a Bachelor in Social Science. That about sums up the entirety of her, to be honest.

https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/purity.png
Insom
Posts: 4653
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

perhaps Trioli is just to the right of Leon Trotsky and a wall, but is she wrong? is Lionhelm not drawing a bit of a long bow when he summarises Hanson-Young’s position as ‘all men are rapists’?
PornoPete
Posts: 3248
Location: Melbourne, Victoria

Hanson-young is a peddler of rape culture theory.

It's an accurate summary.

But beware the motte and bailey fallacy that attends the position. She will say "teach men not to rape" means something other than all men are rapists who have been socially conditioned to dominate women and must be taught not to do it.

Fwiw I disagree Virginia is an activist. I think she is generally a pretty balanced and she should hold his feet to the fire. I don't think it was a particularly compelling outing on her behalf.
Nmag
Posts: 1034
Location: Sydney, New South Wales